Bayside Bargains — Attraction in Sturgeon Bay

I used like going there before I dropped off a chair, mirror, bookshelf, end table, a expensive wooden beat box (drum) and vacuum. And a day and a half later driving by and saw my chair put on the curb. Went into the store to look for all my other stuff and just the vacuum and bookshelf was there. I asked them why my chair was out in the rain and they said that it wasn't sellable. They didn't even give it a chance. And asked where was my other stuff and they said we'll maybe it sold you'll have to wait until next month to see and get paid. So I waited until then and look the store over again for my stuff and nothing The only thing that sold was the mirror and I got $5 for it.

BEWARE!!!! Your better off taking your stuff to a donation center and getting the write off before taking it there and never getting what you thought would be a little cash in your pocket. I WILL NOT BE BACK AGAIN!!!! Half the staff is rude and the other half makes excuses for the missing items . Poor,...

I love this place. My wife and I frequent often, and we always joke that we have to go in "with a plan," because we will end up walking out with some miraculous treasure we weren't expecting!

The items are diverse, the shipments move quickly, and all of the staff are really awesome and hearty.

We have been shopping here for over a year, and I would like to say we have more and more things starting to fill our house from Bayside!

And if you are trying to sell anything, the set-up is super easy, each seller has a code, and when the item is sold, you get a monthly breakdown of it, you can then either cash it as a check or use it as credit for the next purchase.

Really awesome gem, and definitely worth stopping in to see for yourself if you are...

We stopped here just exploring sturgeon bay for the first time. Really wish we would have brought a truck and trailer! AMAZING furniture for the best prices ever! Cute decor and fun vintage items. We were truly on an enjoyable adventure the whole hour we spent in the store. I ended up picking some beautiful items and they were flexible with price since we got so much. I appreciated that! We can’t wait to...