Pinky Promise Coffee — Restaurant in Sturgeon Bay

THE BEST COFFEE of my life!!! At the first sip of their Columbian Medium roast (with just a touch of cream and sugar), I froze in my tracks. Time stopped. I was overcome by the astonishingly satisfying flavor and balance. I forgot about all of my problems, for just a moment, and sunk into that perfection of their roast. It's rare for me to find that perfect balance of flavorful and bold without being overly acidic or bitter, while also not being watery or too weak, and THIS was it.

After that first sip, I had to tell someone, so I told Robert who was working behind the counter, just how much I loved this coffee. Robert was, from the start, so incredibly friendly and helpful, and a real pleasure to talk to. Robert warmly thanked me and said he'd pass my compliment to the owner.

For the next hour, I sat in the small, but very comfortable seating area, and began what I came for: To get on WIFI and work on my laptop and try to get something meaningful done. Not only did I get it done, I basically redesigned my worklife. I attribute my success in this (which I'd wanted to do for months) to the positive energy of that Columbian medium roast, the friendiness of Robert, and the warmth and optimism of the guests and staff that came in.

As if this wasn't already an amazing morning, Robert also introduced me to the owner, Sean, who told me a little about his roasting process (this has been his passion for 20 years!) One by one, really friendly people and staff came through the doors, and Robert introduced me to basically everyone that would be good for me to know in the local arts and music community, of which I am a new member.

I left Pinky Promise and went on to have probably the most productive and satisfying day I can recall in probably the past 5 years.

Thank you Sean, thank you Robert, thank you...

Nestled in the heart of our community lies a true gem for coffee aficionados and casual sippers alike – Pinky Promise Coffee. Stepping into this cozy sanctuary feels like entering a realm where time slows down, and every cup is crafted with passion and expertise.

The coffee itself is sourced from the finest beans around the globe and roasted to perfection, each cup is a symphony of flavor, complexity, and depth. Whether you prefer the bold intensity of a dark roast or the delicate nuances of a single-origin pour-over, Pinky Promise Coffee has something to delight every palate.

But it's not just about the coffee here; it's about the sense of community that permeates every corner of the space. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you're welcomed with open arms and genuine hospitality. It's the kind of place where strangers become friends over shared stories and shared cups of joe, where the simple act of enjoying a beverage becomes a catalyst for connection and camaraderie.

In a world where coffee shops seem to pop up on every corner, Pinky Promise Coffee stands out as a true beacon of excellence. It's more than just a place to grab a latte; it's a destination, a haven, a sanctuary...

First off, I should tell you that I"m one of those pretentious coffee snobs. I admit it. So when I say that I was impressed, I was. Ther roast their own coffee and you can taste it. My only regret was that I stopped in for "just an 2nd morning coffee" and once I sampled how good it was I wish I'd gotten an espresso in addition to really sample that as well. Staff was very friendly. I also really enjoyed that attached art store with was not your generic sampling of resort town paintings of lighthouses and beaches. I really enjoyed the selection of...