Play N Trade — Attraction in Town of Brookhaven

Hands down the ABSOLUTE BEST video game store in all of New York! Went in to trade in a brand new Xbox One and got a great deal that couldn't be beat by competitors. GameStop offered $90 and Play n Trade doubled that! The owner talked and joked around with us like old friends for the 15 minutes we were there, making us feel welcome and left us leaving in a better mood than when we entered. The store is impeccably clean and tidy, everything is easy to find, and they have a wide range of collectibles I've never seen anywhere else. If you need a game for ANY CONSOLE, be it the old school NES or a brand new PS4, they'll have it. I cannot recommend this...

Do not go here. They offered me almost nothing for a switch, a bunch of switch games, and a bunch of Xbox games, game on offered me 400 for all of it while they offered me 120. Not to mention the employees are super rude, constantly making up their own prices/rules as they see fit. The guy at the counter constantly interrupted me as I was speaking, scolded me for not having any game cases, and when I said "have a good day" just straight up ignored me. Everything here is also super expensive. I would rate zero stars if possible, do not waste your time or money here, game on and GameStop are both MUCH...

Used and new games (mostly used) for virtually every video game console ever released. They have Atari, Game Gear, even Virtual Boy. Some of it is pricey but is competitive with prices you find on Ebay and Amazon. They don't always have what I want but it's fun to go and look anyway. Sure you could just order any game you want online but where's the fun in that? The staff is knowledgeable and the store hours are lengthy. They even let you try a game before you buy it! Overall great store for old and hard to find games! I visit at least...