Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay — Attraction in Town of Oyster Bay

Went here to see how much I could get for a passed down engagement ring. The older gentlemen (didn’t get his name) was very condescending. Gave us such a low price then proceeded to tell us that they would sell it for much higher if we were to sell to them (why are you telling us this?) Also told us that a custom fitting (isn’t every fitting custom?) would be more than the actual ring. Went over to an actual jeweler a town over who offered a much higher and better price for the ring and a new setting+fitting. They even told us we were lowballed by this place. If you want to get...

I would like to give this guy owner specifically a no star review. I would have preferred a lesson on how my money was a replica instead of an attitude as if I was trying to get one over on the business. So now that Google has explained how my money wasn’t real………. Was it a British knock off from the 1800s? Or a replica from somewhere between the 60s or 70s? Your rudeness was completely unacceptable. Flat out. If you’re having a bad day go ahead and stay home. I guess the only way you got this one star is the respectful woman in the blue cast. I hope she heals well and has...

Do not even step into this companies location. I went to the Levittown store today to ask two gold chains were worth. The staff looked and offered me $875.00. As I was about to leave, they asked me what I wanted for the pieces and I knew right away to run, not walk out of this store. I went to another vendor a few hours later by accident and when I asked them about the price of the gold, I was immediately offered more than 22% more!!! Think about that....22% more. These people are looking to rip people off...do not let them...