Jonathan's Fine Jewelry — Local services in Batesville

My wife and I took some silver flatware that we were considering selling to Johnathan. He told us to leave it with him and he would look at it and weigh it. We expected an estimate or appraisal, instead he gave us a check. No receipt nor any description of the transaction. When we asked how much it weighed and how much per ounce he paid us, he could not/would not tell us. We had weighed our silver on the bathroom scales and, based on the current price of 22.90 per ounce, we had estimated our silver to be worth close to 9000.00. Imagine our shock and frustration when he gave us 1800.00 and refused to give us a receipt and refused to tell us what it weighed and the price he paid per ounce. Not only did he take our silver for a fraction of what we believe it was worth, he avoided paying taxes on it by refusing to have a paper trail. I do not recommend taking your silver and gold to this man. Any other option is...

I recently got engaged and the ring needed to be sized bigger due to a surgery I had on my hand, so I called around a few places and Johnathan’s was the only one that talked me through everything and made me feel extremely comfortable and not embarrassed on having to get it sized bigger. The staff was amazing when I went in and I can’t wait to get my ring when it’s finished! Thank you for being so kind and not rude when I called asking questions and getting me right in that day! I will only use Johnathan’s from...

Johnathan’s had a watch I really liked advertised online. Living in Indiana I originally questioned how smooth this transaction could go given they are located in Houston. I ended up buying the watch and the transaction process couldn’t of gone any better! Solid communication throughout the entire process and Keifer did exactly what he said he would do. Watch showed up as represented and I couldn’t be...