Hidden Gem Sports Collectibles — Local services in Hackettstown

Happened to be visiting a friend in town and while waiting for him to get ready stumbled upon this "hidden gem" of a card collectable shop. Went in to kill some time and got to talking with the team there. I happened to have a expensive card in my car that I was planning on sending to psa on my own and brought it in to the store to show them. Turns out they had a sub going out so decided to leave it with them. Now keep in mind, I have never met them or spoken to them and felt comfortable enough to leave (a 900 dollar card at the time) with them before heading back home almost.90 miles away so needless to say I was nervous. These guys were not only great but found a couple of imperfections on the card that they were able to fix. The card cake back a psa 10. The communication was great. Service was great and so was the work they did on the card. I couldn't be happier with the experience and glad I went with my gut and left the card with them. I highly recommend this team to anyone who wants to sub with them. Go by the store and see for yourself. They are the real deal. Good luck to you guys and I wish you great success as you grow. I'll be...

Hidden Gem is a great local card store. Lou Jr. and Lou Sr. are very patient and knowledgeable. My boys and I were new to the PSA grading submissions and they walked us through the process. To date, we've had 4 cards submitted to PSA for grading by Hidden Gem and all 4 have come back with a...

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ “Hidden Gem truly lives up to its name! A great father and son shop with an awesome selection of sports cards and memorabilia. Friendly service, honest feedback, and fair prices every time. Great place to also consider submitting cards to grade. Highly recommend to collectors of...