Broadway Tire — Local services in Town of Babylon

all i needed today was two used tires, which granted, they provided for me quickly; however they did not act professional at all. Sal was projecting a fight he was having with his wife onto me and my husband, which made me very uncomfortable having to play therapist for a man twice my age. He made a “joke” about how women are never happy and told my husband to discipline me by choking me, and said “she would like that though, wouldn’t she?”

it made the both of us sick to our stomachs

needless to say, i was completely irate trying not to scream at him, holding my tongue so i could just pay and leave and he had the audacity to say “look, i was right, she’s blushing”

never have i been treated this way by another human in any setting and especially not in front of my husband. you lost two loyal customers today because you couldn’t just act like a normal person. your 7 year old acted more mature than you did and that’s probably thanks to his mother, who you seem to hate. I shouldn’t have to know that as a customer, either.

run away from this place if...

I’m extremely disappointed with Broadway Tire Shop in North Amityville. They’re charging the same price for used tires as you’d pay for brand new ones elsewhere—it’s outrageous. As someone who supports local businesses, I expected fair pricing and honest service, but this felt like I was being taken advantage of.

What’s even more frustrating is that this business has been part of our community for over 50 years and has never given anything back—not to the kids, not to the schools, not to the people. No sponsorships, no events, no outreach—nothing. Just taking money from the neighborhood without ever investing back into it.

At this point, it feels like they’re robbing us blind. We deserve better. North Amityville...

Shredded a tire on the recently re-surfaced Northern State Parkway. Luckily did not lose control, but definitely driving on a rim until I could pull over on wide shoulder. Was recommended Broadway Tire/Sal in Amityville on 110, and glad I was l, indeed. Don't be put off by the informal vibe, this is not a large corporate place, but a caring local business. Thought I needed a rim repaired, I did not...they had a tire in stock, tire rotation, recalibration and donut put back in trunk, with everything back in place.

Honest, hard-working group of guys, reasonable price, more than competent service=Highest...