NoFo Pot Pies Country Market — Local services in Town of Southold

This is a wonderful addition to Mattituck, with really delicious pot pies that you take home frozen and cook to perfection in your home oven. We had the turkey pot pie and it was amazing, with the perfect blend of tender meat and super fresh vegetables. They also have a ton of other quality food products available. You could put together a wonderful gift package for a host as a one stop shop here. Really well done.

(Tip: when cooking the pot pies, put them on top of a sheet pan lined with parchment paper or foil. They tend to bubble over a little and this makes for an...

I have liked everything I’ve tried so far. Each time I go in, I have a hard time deciding what I want to get next. I have bought the carrot cake multiple times, I like the fact it doesn’t have raisins, and the frosting is perfect! The store itself is beautiful! It is organized and really clean. Every time I’ve gone in the woman there is cleaning something while she helps customers find what they are looking for by sharing information about the products. She really knows a lot about the business. Very impressed. I stop here instead of ordering...

Delish!! This Mattituck stand alone store is really cute and chocked full treats. Not just pot pies—in 10 different flavor combos—but also desserts, breads, salad dressings, marinades, sides, and on and on. We are working our way through the pot pies and each is unique and really delicious. Current fave: Jambalaya! Join their “points” program and you can earn a $20 reward towards the purchase of something delicious. Who doesn’t love a freebie plus not having to...