Old Mill Family Restaurant — Restaurant in District Municipality of Muskoka

This was a beautiful - yet unassuming from the outside - family restaurant located in the heart of town. It was a very lovely visit, with great staff, and a warm and inviting atmosphere.

The food was excellent and the staff were very friendly. You know it's a good spot when all the locals go there, and do they ever! I listened as the waitress said hello to every customer as they walked in - by name! We were pretty much the only ones she didn't recognize, but she treated us just as warmly as she did her regulars. A couple of her customers took the time to fill her in on their nice vacation away, as she previously said "Hey insert first names here! I haven't seen you in a while, it's good to see you!" And the warmth and family environment could immediately be felt by that relationship between her and the customers.

The food was excellent, and the portions were HUGE for what you paid for. When I left, I felt like I was robbing the place for the price I paid and the amount of food we ate!

Don't pass this place up, it might not look like much on the outside... but you get so much more when you walk...

We got fish and chips and the burger combo, both were great. If you like burgers you'll definitely like these burgers. I usually get annoyed at places for their burger buns, I want a toasted bun and not have it squished when I get it to go. The meat was juicy and bun was great, it really hit the spot. My wife had the fish and chips and she liked hers a lot, wasn't too much batter or oil, and she even got some onion rings with it.

It was a little more expensive than I thought it would be but man they give you a ton of food, not just some tiny burger/fish and a mountain of fries. It was a decent sized burger/fish and a ton of fries, so you're definitely getting your money's worth. We couldn't finish everything and had some for later.

Just make sure you check the time by calling in if you wanted to dine-in. The Google times were not accurate we could only do take-out after 3pm. We called in and it took about 15-20 mins to get our food. I would definitely recommend this place if you're not sure what to get...

We were visiting from the Big Smoke (Toronto) for some fall foliage viewing. We didn't want to eat in a fast food place so decided to give this place a try. We were asked for our covid 2nd vaccine proof and when I showed her mine, she barely looked at it. We were seated in a large booth with plenty of space from other customers. It seemed as there was only 1 waitress working that day. My brother ordered Cheeseburger/Fries and a coffee while I ordered a Chicken Clubhouse Sandwich/Fries and a Coke. It took at least 30 minutes to get our food as place was fairly busy and not sure how many people working in the kitchen. The only problem with our order was my Club. The Chicken Breast was thick and bulky and there were no Tomatoes on my Sandwich and for $15.99 I would hope Tomatoes be included. The Sandwich was only cut in half and hard to eat and messy with the fillings slipping out. When I asked waitress she quickly bought me a plate of 2 tomatoes (that's what I asked for). All in all, nice quaint place...