Pizzajerrys/Pete's Pizza — Restaurant in St. Catharines

A few years ago, I stopped ordering from here because I went to pick up a pizza about 40 minutes (they told me it would be ready in 35) and when I showed up they said it has not been made yet. No problem. So not 5 minutes later the server brings my pizza out to me. I open the box and the crust is not even browned and the cheese is barely melted. I turned around and left.

Recently I decided to give the place a second chance, and had a few good pizzas from them.

Just tonight, I go pick up my order, and while driving home, I notice a funky smell from the pizza box. After trying 2 slices (that i could barely lift as it was so soggy and greasy) I realize that the cheese tastes way off... Completely inedible.

Brought it back and was given my money back (minus the gratuity I left) and was told by the cook that the cheese was grated only 2 days ago and it must be the anchovies that smell bad. It does not take an expert to tell what bad cheese tastes like. I ordered the same toppings as I do at every pizza location, and have never had such a foul tasting pizza before.

Will not be returning here.

note to owner after viewing your response

Your pizzeria sold a pizza with near expired ingredients. I know the difference between the smell of anchovies (every pizza I buy for myself has them on it) and the smell of bad cheese.

Why do you still have a pizza box from an item returned the night before? Because if you did, you would have seen the puddle of grease in it.

And why would I waste my time to bring the pizza back if there was nothing wrong with it?

We both know who is full of sh** about this situation, and...

We’ve ordered takeout a handful of times from here. We have a few spots that we like to rotate and we have little kids so many times go with most affordable option. Always have a good meal when we’ve gotten takeout. We find some places make a better pep and cheese pizza than they do with lots of toppings and vice versa. Pizza Jerry’s is excellent for both.

What reminded me to come on here to leave a review was our first dining in experience the other night. They have a great family meal deal for dining in that I kept wanting to try. Food was as usual delicious but what made it stand out and so helpful was that they have a bunch of arcade games for the kids and it’s free. My kids loved it and it was a way better option for them than going to a busy, big and loud place like Boston pizza. My husband and I actually got to enjoy our meal and the kids came back and forth to the table as we were right next to games. It’s hard to take kids out as you either don’t want them disrupting other tables or their attention span isn’t long and before you know it they’re squirmy and need something to do. So between chicken wing and pizza bites they were able to play some games. We felt welcomed and we were able to take the kids out for an affordable fun night with very little stress. The waitress was very kind and accommodating. For reference our boys are 9, 7 and 5 but we only had to the two younger ones...

This business deserves to be the "Best of the Best" They make the best pizza in town. They do not skimp on the amount of toppings, and no matter whether it is picked up or delivered, it is always hot. The staff is always friendly and helpful, willing to go the extra mile for their customers. it would seem like they may shortly need more staff as the last time I was in to pick up a pizza the young woman could hardly keep up with the phone customers. Listening to the easy friendly way she handled the customers I did not mind waiting til she finished 3-4 calls ( in fact she couldn't get away from the phone) so she could go to the kitchen to bring out our pizza. I would not deal with any otaher pizza business in town. Lady Joan Dewar-Adair Lady Laird of...