Maker Pizza Carlaw - NOW at 181B Carlaw! — Restaurant in Toronto

If you are thinking about ordering Maker Pizza here is how it will go....

You and your (insert whoever) decide to order pizza. One of you says "Hey, Maker is new in the Hood, Let's check it out!" Google Maker Pizza Carlaw Check out the menu, looks really good maybe a bit $$ Order...oh wait need to download an app - ok Download, install, sign up, authenticate, load payment OK ready to order. One 'Return of the Mac' please $37.00 yikes but whatever Sorry we don't deliver....that's ok it is on my way home from work Pick up it is.....it's only 7pm now....lets say 8pm pick up Sounds perfect ORDERED for pick up 714pm text received Order received. Pick up time 810pm follow instructions when you arrive. Great! 806pm open instructions press "I've arrived" button Please wait patiently in your car or outside (-13C) until you receive "Order Ready" message and come on in (lucky I drove). 815pm notice many people waiting in cars out front 825pm notice people still waiting in cars all over the street 830pm notice one person leave with a pizza (ok good I know they are open) 840pm person in car in front of you goes inside (ok I must be next) 845pm person from in front comes back no pizza ask "What time was your pick up?" response "830pm they just told me could be 5mins could be 45mins" 850pm check app no cancel button anywhere 852pm go inside....several other people waiting 855pm umm Can I cancel please? "Of course I told them to stop taking orders a long time ago" I actually preordered awhile ago......silence Ok your order is cancelled. Leave empty handed, hungry and annoyed. 926pm TEXT your order is ready!!!

Sorry Blondies that is what we get for trying something...

This is a pick up pizza location only! Ordered online for the 2nd time last night around 7pm and the process was so smooth (my order was saved from 3 months ago). Each time I have ordered it does take about 20-25 minutes before your pizza is ready and if you get it delivered that will add some time too so it's good to plan a little ahead. They allow you to customize many aspects (more cheese? More sauce? Hot honey? Etc) of your pizza but given my inexperience with their pies, for the 2nd time I went with the standard offering which still really hit the spot. They keep your pizza warm until pick up at 145°F and it is best to eat it right away to get the best experience. Usually order pizza to suit my 11 year old so far we have tried the pepperoni and the Margherita and haven't branched out beyond that. Two 12 inches are a great size for 3 hungry women. We love the super thin crust and simplicity of the margherita-- it was polished off first (might order 2 marg next time!!) I don't usually eat pizza bc I have to take half a bottle of lactaid but I do it for this pizza. It's a treat! I like a little brio to drink. IYKYK. They do also have option to remove cheese and one marinara pizza but if what you're looking for is accommodation for everyone's food sensitivities/preferences I.e gluten free/lactose free/vegan etc Blondies has...

It’s probably been a few weeks since I last ordered from here and I always order pizza and garlic fingers with extra donair sauce to go with the pizza. And tonight I was disappointed to find out the donair sauce has been changed. It’s now very thick (kind of looks like straight up mayonnaise), smells and tastes closer to garlic sauce than donair sauce. I’m quite sad to see they’ve changed half of the reason I eat from Maker Pizza and that it will probably be a very long time before I order from there for myself. I regret ordering the extra sauce tonight as I will not eat it and I hate wasting things. I’m a sauce with my pizza kinda girly and when they started allowing you to order extra donair with the garlic fingers I was so excited because I eat it with my pizzas too, but this sauce is just not it. I hope people see my review before ordering the donair sauce in case they’re expecting the delicious original version. I also hope whoever at Maker Pizza thought changing the recipe was a good idea, that they see my review and maybe others will want the original too and it gets changed back. Please...