North of Brooklyn Pizzeria — Restaurant in Toronto

Oct. 5, 2025...update...OMG 🤬. Once again this place arbitrarily cancels our oder but cheerfully charges us and expects me to accept waiting for that to be refunded 3 days later! Nutty way to run a business. I chose the option to be contacted if there is a problem with the order....I DID NOT choose to have my fricking order cancelled EVERYTIME. Why do I keep trying? That's on me. Another irritating fail at this place. 0 stars for the food since I have NO idea how it tastes lately. March 13, 2024 update...okay the take-out pizza may occasionally be cancelled, but the absolutely stellar response from head office (presumably) has been lovely! Really appreciated the personal response and explanation. Good pizza is one thing, good people are another. North of Brooklyn has both. (And yes, the service stars went from 1⭐ to 4⭐⭐⭐⭐ thanks to K*'s response.... Happy to boost it to 5 the next time unsuccessfully get a takeout pizza!)

March 8, 2024 update...cancel culture at the Geary Avenue North of Brooklyn strikes again. Sigh. Order accepted. Order confirmed. Order cancelled. I was foolish to try again on a Friday. 2023 - Have gone here for years (Covid excepted) & done takeout pizza. Lovely atmosphere and aside from a long wait for food it's solid. But don't bother with takeout! They'll charge your credit card and then send an email cancelling your order! Has happened 3x recently. Last time we didn't see the email - because who constantly checks email on a Friday night?! I waited 25minutes in line only to be told it was probably cancelled because they couldn't get it done on time!! Other than that suggestion the staff wad obviously overwhelmed and not in a position to care about my cancelled order. VERY irritating that they've still charged us!! Aside from this feeling a bit like a reverse restaurant robbery...how about having systems in place where a) you don't charge a customer until you've provided the product, and b) you have a separate line for pizza pickup so I don't have to wait 25 minutes to be told my order has been cancelled. Eat in. Do NOT takeout. Also need...

Located in a non-descript corner in the middle of quaint Davenport neighbourhood, this place was an oasis that I randomly discovered on a quiet Sunday afternoon. Our group of 8 family and friends were hungry and we were in the mood for pizza. We likely would not have even ventured in if it were not for passing a couple carrying a small stack of pizza boxes coming out of the place while we were standing outside deciding to go in or not. Glad we did. The pizza order desk is inside and shares the space with the Greater Good pub. Their pizzas are the thin crust type and they have some interesting toppings to choose from as well as their own combination favorites. GREAT pizza, crisp and flavourful. We had the Kale & Bacon and Puttanesca. We just had pop from the Greater Good bar, but we were impressed with the craft beer selection they had cleverly listed on large menu boards above the bar. Friendly service and nice relaxed atmosphere. No intrusive background music which I appreciated. Bonus is that while waiting for your order, you can kill time in the arcade that they have upstairs...retro arcade games, pinball, foosball and skeeball! Awesome place to come chill out and satisfy the munchies. I will definitely look for this place the next time...

I recently had an unfortunate experience with North of Brooklyn Pizzeria that left me quite disappointed. I placed an order for a dinner for two, along with a special Meati Pie pizza. However, upon delivery, I was informed that they didn't have the Meati Pie pizza available. This was disappointing, as I was looking forward to trying that specific pizza.

To resolve the issue, I had to reorder my second pizza, and to my surprise, I was charged double for the delivery of the second pizza. This unexpected additional cost was frustrating and felt unfair, considering it was due to their inability to provide the pizza I initially ordered.

To add to my disappointment, when the revised order arrived, they had forgotten to include the Garlic Knots with my Dinner for two. This oversight was frustrating, as it was a part of the original order that I was eagerly anticipating.

Overall, my experience with North of Brooklyn Pizzeria was disappointing. The unavailability of the Meati Pie pizza, the additional delivery charge, and the missing Garlic Knots from my order all contributed to a negative dining experience. I hope the pizzeria takes these issues seriously and improves their service to avoid such disappointments for their customers...