Pin-Up Pizza — Restaurant in Atlantic City

My wife and I were both born and raised in New Jersey, so our bar for pizza and subs is a little higher than most. We currently live in Virginia, but make the trip back to Atlantic City 6-7 times a year. We decided to try this place the last time we were at Harrah’s (July 2025). I got two slices of pizza and two Italian subs for my wife and I, and this is by far the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Better off throwing the pizza away and eating the box it was given to us in. The subs were also terrible. Cheap meat, stale bread. Service was very slow- over 20 minutes to make the subs with pre-sliced meat, despite there being absolutely nobody else in there at the time. Cheap lesson I guess, as after spending almost $60.00 with tip, we know now that we’ll never go back to this place again. Would give it zero stars in every catagory. We always stay at Harrah’s, but usually head over to Caesars for the better food options. The best thing that could happen to Harrah’s AC would be for this place to close...

Ordered 3 different slices and mozzarella sticks.

Sicilian Pepperoni Buffalo chicken

Mozzarella sticks had good flavor, but the cheese wasn’t fully melted so it wasn’t that good.

The Sicilian slice was very dry, needed more sauce and cheese.

The Buffalo chicken was the worst one and was the driest. The chicken had the flavor but was over cooked for sure.

The pepperoni slice was my favorite as it wasn’t dry and it tasted good.

I saw some of the pies they sold and they were HUGE, for $35. I’d probably order either plain or the pepperoni pie to make it worth it.

At $7 a slice, it should have some top notch ingredients. A $2 slice taste better than these unfortunately.

Service was quick, waited less than 5 minutes...

Me and my boyfriend never had such bad pizza. He's from New York and I am from New Jersey. We couldn't even eat this if we were drunk. I wish we were! It is 3:30 in the afternoon! I would give this place 0 stars if u could. Because what really gets me is I am a former smoker and as I bit a piece of the crust and it tasted like ashtray. I am utterly sick to my stomach. I have a nasty taste in my mouth and I can not get rid of.

The pie itself was a cheese pie. Wasn't cooked fully. Cheese overload with sauce.. oh what where was the sauce. I am highly disappointed since this was my first day in A.C. ever!! Stay away unless you like doughy pizza mixed with a...