3 Guys Pizzeria — Restaurant in Belleville

This is a nice pizzeria with a good staff, good pizza and great prices. Their grandma's pizza, white cheese with bacon and meatza(a little small but worth it) slices were very delicious and unique, their bacon is very nice and crunchy. However, their bbq chicken, buffalo chicken and penne vodka could be improved, along with their pick up time for 1 20" pizza(50 minutes is too long of a wait time, especially when the employee on the phone told me 20 minutes). The problem with the specialties: Bbq chicken while delicious, needed to be covered in more cheese on top and needs something extra like bacon or something to compliment the sweetness. Buffalo chicken was WAAAY too spicy and chicken pieces itself were overcooked and needed to be coated with more cheese (pieces kept falling off, i bought this as a pie, not slice) maybe even a little blue cheese as well. Penne vodka had very good noodles but whole slice was bland due to very little vodka sauce. Maybe try to put vodka sauce in replacement of pizza tomato sauce? Although staff was friendly, they definitely needed to pay more attention and make sure when someone is waiting a long time for an order, the customer isn't waiting for the staff to notice a pizza was done, instead of having the customer assist the employee to let them know their pizza was done. Very nice selection of soda too.

Overall good but could be excellent if...

It is with regret that I pen this review for 3 Guys Pizza, a dining experience that unfortunately fell short of expectations.

To begin with, the overpowering saltiness of the food significantly detracted from my enjoyment. While a touch of salt is usually welcome to enhance flavor, the pizzas at 3 Guys were over-seasoned to the point where the natural tastes of the ingredients were entirely masked. It seemed as though each bite was more salt-laden than the last, making it a challenge to finish a slice.

Furthermore, the pizzas were markedly greasy, which only exacerbated the issue of excessive salt. The combination of the two resulted in a heavy, unappetizing meal that was difficult to enjoy.

Additionally, the wings we ordered were served cold, a stark contrast to the piping hot, freshly cooked wings one might expect at a pizzeria. The lack of heat made the texture unappealing, and the wings were, like the pizzas, excessively salty.

Ultimately, my visit to 3 Guys Pizza was marred by these issues. The culinary experience was overwhelmingly characterized by a symphony of salt and grease, which did not align with the expectations I had for the meal. I’m hopeful that 3 Guys Pizza will take this feedback into account and rectify these issues for a more balanced, enjoyable dining experience...

Only order from this place if you want garbage for dinner. I ordered a Grandma style pizza with extra cheese and mushrooms and it was nothing short of a nightmare. Firstly, this pizza with a bottle of ginger ale is going to cost you $25, so I hope you have money to burn. When it arrives over an hour later it will be cold and sloppy with a crust that is under cooked in the middle, but over cooked on the edges. The sauce will be sour, the mushrooms will be raw and dirty and the cheese will be unmelted. Then when you call to complain you will be told that it's your fault for ordering your pizza this way. Also, that I must be thinking of Digiorno's or some other insult. So, I'm the reason that they can't make pizza and I deserve now to be insulted to boot. Well, unless your grandmother couldn't cook and was abusive, this pizza will in no way remind you of your grandmother. I'm originally from San Bartolomeo in Galdo, Italy. I also used to be a chef. I think I know a thing or two...