Plosky's Deli — Restaurant in Carbondale

We literally just left and it was the most disappointing experience my husband and I have ever had here. The front-facing staff were very nice (as always), however I could audibly hear the chef complaining about my order with very simple modifications (cut in half, wrapped separately because I was sharing the sandwich with my mother who is visiting town). The manager or owner was conversing with the chef about his complaining stating that modifications have to be made. The sandwich came out wrapped as a whole, and the other modifications weren't done to the sandwich. If you're expecting people to pay about $20 dollars per sandwich, you'd expect to have your modifications delivered how you ordered your sandwich. My husband come in often, and we were really excited to show here. Nonetheless, this was a very disappointing experience, especially when we tip 20%+ on takeout. This visit left a very bad taste about the kitchen operations. I would have rather discuss it in person, but since we need to go home and re-make our sandwiches, we left in a hurry.

Hi Dave, thank you for the prompt response. I can definitely empathize with the trainees. I also apologize for my misunderstanding of your conversation with the chef. Thank you for the offer, we will definitely take you up on that some time. Thank you again, I appreciate you taking the time to reach...

When I decided that I was going to be moving to Carbondale and the Central Rockies from the culinary Mecca of Northern California, I definitely wasn't expecting a Jewish deli in my new city, and certainly not one steps away from my home. So you can imagine my pleasant surprise when I saw one through the window of my U-Haul two days ago upon my arrival. Why it took me two days to get here is a question I'll continue to ask myself because Plosky's delivers and more! From the friendly staff to the comfy atmosphere to the AMAZING culinary treats, I can safely say I've never had a deli quite like this anywhere I've lived, let alone in the middle of the mountains. While I haven't tried their bagels yet, they look awesome in the display case and I'm sure I'll be taking a half dozen home with me next time. Whether you're a local like me or dropping by on your way to Aspen/Snowmass, you're doing yourself a disservice if you don't stop by Plosky's for a bite to eat. Trust me, you won't be...

I’m visiting from out of town and thought I’d give this place a try. My wife and I went in to order takeout from the counter. The vibe was very welcoming— bright, clean, modern. Nostalgic 90’s rock. A cool and comfortable looking lounge area.

It’s a particularly busy day due to the Mountain Fair nearby, so we did have to wait about 20 mins for our order to be ready, and there wasn’t a very obvious, comfortable place to stand in the meantime— always felt like we were in someone’s way.

I ordered the pastrami on rye. It was extremely good. Great balance of flavors, and fresh tasting bread. My wife ordered the greek sneak, and she said it was good, but not amazing— bread was a little flimsy and insides fell out.

We would definitely and happily go back. My wife wants to try the salads which she said looked really good, from what she saw others eating. My rating is giving a little benefit of the doubt, because I suspect our experience would be better on a less...