Pie Whole Pizza — Restaurant in Charlotte Amalie

Update:

Felt I needed to come back as the Old Pie Whole is back. Had my pineapple pizza with bell peppers as I’ve had for years. We were happy to say it was perfect!

Absolute worst Pie Whole Pizza I ever had. It saddens me to leave this review as I send so many guests there and have used them many times.

Ordinarily I would not do a review and instead call the location. I actually attempted to call to avoid anyone else get this mess I got last night 02/17/23 at 730pm.

I ordered three pies simple pineapple and peppers. What I got in the boxes were three burnt crust with the largest bell peppers, many slices without one piece of pineapple. We attempted to eat some but four people ate one of three boxes and threw out two full boxes.

I saddens me that they had the audacity to place this mess in boxes and thought it was okay. I understand that the gratuity given for take out is understandably less than dine in but the restaurant should discontinue take out if that is what they choose to send out. (PS I’ve had take out as recently as two weeks ago which was just fine).

This experience is one where I felt robbed paying $95.00 for a pizza! It is my last experience with Pie While as well...

My wife and I went there for dinner and had the worst experience. When we entered we noticed it wasn't that busy, so we went to the back of the restaurant and sat at a booth. Apparently sitting in the booth for just the two of us was a problem...we said hello to our waitress and she did not respond, all she asked was, "is it just you two sitting here?" In which we responded yes. She walked away and started whispering to the bar tender, looking over at us, and laughing / rolling her eyes. If they wanted us to move at a smaller table, we could have easily I would not have had a problem. But it was not busy and we wanted a booth instead of a table since they said we could seat ourselves as we walked inside. After that incident with her, she only spoke with us two more times that entire evening. She asked if we were ready to order, and if we wanted the check. I watched her check on other diners, refilled drinks, etc. She did not with us. She one time grabbed my water, filled it, and put it down without say a word to us. She didn't ask if we wanted more drinks, food, anything. Very rude and couldn't believe the bad service we received. Would...

This restaurant was walking distance from our hotel and was listed on the map provided by the management. We selected this place for lunch and ordered the hurricane pizza (cooked in a real brick oven) . It was absolutely delicious!... more so than a lot of the dedicated pizza joints in Austin Texas (where we're from) and a lot of other places/cities for that matter. We will be back for dinner as they have several pasta dishes including fettuccine alfredo , stromboli, chicken parmesan, beef or shrimp tacos, wings, and much more. They have a full bar also. The very friendly wait person was personable and attentive. If we lived nearby, we would be regulars here. Prices were very reasonable...more so than some other nearby restaurants. But, MAN!...was that pizza good! [UPDATE] We returned for dinner. I had the stromboli and the wife had the penne arrabbiata. Both were delicious and HUGE portions. We each took half our order home. Sharing is recommended for small to medium appetites. We had a nice Argentinian Malbec along with our entrée. This is a small, low-keyed restaurant well worth your time...