Mary's Deli — Restaurant in City of Dunkirk

I went here awhile ago. I'm a truck driver and the locals who work at the factory down the street recommended it. I bought one sub and brought it back to my truck to eat it. Before I left for my next destination, I walked all the way back and bought two more for dinner that night and one more just because. Italian Stallion is the only one I remember. I had gardenia peppers on it I think. I remember the other two being pretty awesome as well.

I remember walking up to the joint and seeing it looking like a dingy old place with grease everywhere thinking they don't ever clean. Had to have been a health hazard I thought but saw the line of people starting to gather at 430 in the afternoon. For me, it's an odd indicator of a good restaurant. Even though it looked like a place needing to be condemned, people still lining up outside. Apparently, someone said something. The pictures posted here, look like they've redone the place. If I ever go to Niagara, I'm putting in the extra miles to get another 2 or...

Ok. This review is harder for me. I have never had New York pizza (I'm from kansas) and I dont necessarily like the toppings I ordered (Mary's is a bit expensive so I just got what my friend likes)

It was a decent pizza, idk maybe I dont like Mary's orbi dont like New York style but too much cheese and not enough sauce for me.

The employees were AMAZING! They were so excited to hear it was my first New York slice and asked me where I was from

A.real home town vibe, the prjer customers that came in were treated like family and even though I had to wait a second o was glad to hang with them.

Clean, professional, fun, accommodating.

My friend said shes had problems with the delivery before, the super chill vibe might be a catalyst to that, but pick up is worth it.

I'll try them again when I'm back in Dunkirk. Hope they have an amazing...

Will never go here again.  I dont like to be lied to.  Waited a hour to get my food while they made phone call orders first. Went in twice to see what was taking so long and he kept saying they aren't ready yet still cooking. As I was standing there a large order of food was sitting on the counter all ready for the delivery guy to take. Made all that before they made my order and I was a walk in. Got the calzones home and they weren't cooked enough and the marinara sauce was way too sweet and didn't care for it at all. Very very disappointed. Never again. I'll be taking my business...