Milton Point Provisions — Restaurant in City of Rye

We wanted to go out for a fun date night as we recently moved in together to the area but we’re really disappointed. After $75 we left hungry, and thirsty. The layout of the restaurant asks customers to order up front, and food will be brought to you, at 7:01 we ordered two cocktails, two sandwiches, and two waters. At 7:26 we had no waters, food, nor cocktails at our table. A few tables had diners, but other didn’t. Since we paid first, we were asked to tip, and tipped 20%, per usual for us. If it was busier that would have made sense but this felt a bit off… We inquired about our waters, and they were apologetic and handed us waters but it went downhill from there. Our drinks came right after but were the only good part of the evening. The rotisserie chicken was so dry, even though Milton Point Provisions pride themselves on having house made rotisserie chicken. The pulled pork sandwich came with coleslaw on top, even though I asked for it on the side, and it was so dry. When they took it back they just scraped the slaw off because they didn’t get it all. Fries were over salted. Mac and Cheese was cold, and flavorless, and I would have rather made it at home from a box. We both left more than half the food on the plate even though we came in starving and weren’t served food for 30 minutes. When we left the server looked at us and just said “sorry”. Normally not one to write a negative review, and I’m all for understanding one bad night, but multiple diners were being apologized for similar issues to by the wait staff this evening while we were there… just be warned after reading all the...

We’ve lived in Rye for three years and this is one of our favorite places - a little bit off the beaten path from downtown but very quick and easy to get to.

It has a great local feel and all of the food we’ve ordered has always been fantastic. Definitely ask if the smoker is going because the chicken and ribs are unbelievable. I also really like the burger. Another nice thing is they have a fantastic beer selection and are also able to make some pretty tasty cocktails if that’s what you’re looking for.

Well, the food is great the service is even better. The owner of Monty is frequently here and we had a fantastic experiencing sitting at the bar...

Hadley and Milton Point Provisions are ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. The weekend of my daughter’s wedding, we hosted all the bridesmaids for dress/prep on Saturday and then we hosted a Sunday brunch for the two wedding families; on both mornings, Hadley brought the most delicious lunch and brunch goodies. She delivered the very best croissants, mixed berry salads, coffee, wraps (gluten-free/veggie and whole wheat/chicken/avocado), crudités/hummus. I couldn’t have asked for a more delicious or beautiful array of lunch and brunch foods. Thank you so much for making everything so easy for us. We will definitely be calling...