Pizza Amore — Restaurant in Cliffside Park

This is a consistent spot that my friends and I frequent a few times a month for a good pie. It is nice to have a reliable local pizza shop, and this place has been consistent throughout my experience. I have tried their regular pies with toppings which were good, but I was most impressed with their Sicilian pie. This is exactly my style as the doe is nice and fluffy; they put a generous amount of cheese as well which tastes unique. We usually get this pie plain, but it is packed with flavor regardless. If you see the picture, that one square is an entire slice and a pie was enough to feed a few people. Their mozzarella sticks hit the spot, but one thing I always order is their garlic knots which are pure fluffy goodness. I may try one of their sandwiches in the future, but I would opt for one of their hot sandwiches which could be a little pricey. When I say pricey, I mean buying the sandwich would be enough for me to say “this is close enough might as well spend the extra few bucks and get a pizza pie”. That is the only reason why I have yet to try one of their hot sandwiches. A sandwich on its own is not enough for a meal, but it is close enough in price to a plain pizza pie which would be enough food for an entire day which is what has been holding me back. One day if I feel adventurous, I may give it a try. Until then, my peers and I are super happy with their pizzas. We recently ordered their margarita pizza as well which we really liked. Overall, this spot always delivers good consistent product for me. There are a good amount of pizza spots in the area which makes competition fierce, but I believe this spot has a leg up over most of them. I would also add that I normally order takeout, and never really had to wait for my food when getting there. Everything is usually ready in a timely manner when they say it will be which is greatly appreciated and not something that is common in this area..... I would encourage other restaurants I have reviewed on this side of Anderson Ave to take notes because it is nice to finally have a place I be confident about...

Had a large pizza delivered, 1/2 mushroom, 1/2 pepperoni. It arrived hot but was one of the worst pizzas I've eaten. The dough is rubbery and the cheese topping somewhat odd in consistency. I'm an old timer with lots of pizza under my belt. I know NY and Chicago pizza firsthand. This was more like pizza you would get at a highway truckstop. The dough is more like pita than pizza dough. I echo several similar reviews. On the other hand, the eggplant parm which I've had many times is really good. This place changed hands about a year ago. The employees are very polite and attentive and it's very nice doing business with them. I hope that they take these comments seriously and fix...

First time here and will be my last that’s for sure ! I’m sorry to say it but hands down the worst pizza I have ever tried . No flavor at all the pizza dough had no flavor the pizza sauce had no flavor the cheese was the only thing that had flavor the pizza looked crispy and cooked nice but had a lot of flop and again no flavor I order hot wings too they where breaded not your average wings at a pizzeria they had no meat on them all breading very disappointing my whole appetite was horrible wish I never tried this place idk why people say this is the best pizza when completely it’s NOT ! The best thing this place has is the customer service the customer service was good...