Sweetie Pies Pizza — Restaurant in Clifton Heights

The food is very good. I’ve been trying a few things on the menu, the pizza, fries, chicken tenders, the gizmo, the cheesy bread, and the cinnamon sticks. My next targets are cheesesteak, wings, panini, Stromboli and maybe a salad(not a salad guy so I don’t want to skew the score by trying something I’m not a fan of.). So the pizza is very solid, I’m a fan of the sweet sauce, reminds me of Franzone’s in Bridgeport. The dough wasn’t evenly stretched so I had a slice that was a little more doughy than others. I had that happen with multiple pies so, maybe it’s something that’s being worked out. Dough flavor is very good, sauce is good, cheese is good, and I really enjoyed the pepperoni trio. I read a number of reviews that the fries were soggy, but I ordered the chicken finger and gravy fries combo and my fries were hot and crispy despite being covered in gravy. My chicken tenders had great flavor, were juicy, and all white meat, I recommend. Finally the Gizmo, was my most disappointing item, I’d give it a 3 out of 5. I was thinking maybe a cheeseburger hoagie with ham chopped in the mold of a chopped cheese from Harlem, but the burger was dry, the ham wasn’t dispersed evenly, and it just lacked flavor over all. Again I’ll be willing to chalk this one up to maybe a seldomly ordered item being ironed out. In all, the service was very good. Friendly staff, quick delivery, and easy communication. My last delivery was missing the soda, and I had called back. I received an apology, was told they would contact the driver, and have it resent. It was taken care of in short order and very pleasant. The atmosphere is very nice. The restaurant is very clean, quite a bit of an upgrade from Gaetano’s which let’s be real, needed a little of a face lift. Parking is tough, but if you order ahead, side street parking is available. All in all Sweetie Pie’s is carrying a 4.5 stars out of 5 for me. Also I’m missing photos from all the items I ordered but here’s a photo of the pepperoni trio pie, and a large pie...

Had no idea what to expect when I ordered. I got the plain and pepperoni and they were both so good. The crust is perfect and I got the traditional Italian sauce on both. I’m so glad that I don’t have to eat best quality or cimineras anymore this place blows them out of the water. It was so good that I ordered again tonight. I got their sweet sauce cheese pizza which was a hit with my family. Also got the veggie pizza which also was great. Italian hoagie was fantastic it was very traditional and simple but really perfect. The cheesesteak was good quality not too much cheese. The wings I got naked and well done with their hot sauce on the side just in case I wasn’t a fan of the sauce. My goodness the hot sauce was some of the best I’ve ever had and will absolutely get them tossed in it next time. Wings were well done but not over fried. I mean everything was so perfect exactly how I like it. Sometimes I feel like I’m crazy when I think everywhere basically sucks but then I find a place like this and realize that good places still exist! The ONLY downside was the French fries I ordered were not good. They were likely fried with old oil as the French fries were more of a brown color than yellow. I would give the fries another chance but would hope the frying oil would be changed more frequently. I really hope this place can become more popular and be around for years to come. I hope they don’t change and keep their high quality food and service. Can’t wait to...

A night where your ordering system goes down can separate a good food spot from a great business. Sweetie pie is both! They were buzzing with Saturday night orders when we arrived to pick up our dinner. As the employees were sorting through their rush they updated us on the situation apologetically. We quickly received our meals in addition to a complimentary 2 liter for the small delay! Our hot and fresh Stromboli, Buffalo chicken cheese steak and broccoli bites were absolutely delicious. This was our first time trying sweetie pie pizza but we absolutely will be back not only for the amazing food but quality customer service. Coming from the restaurant industry my husband and I completely understand a night in the weeds but a 10 minute delay is nothing on a Saturday night. The food alone is enough to leave a pleasant review but it’s how they handled the situation as professionals working together! The Stromboli was stuffed deliciously and coated with a healthy garlic oil. No skimping on the Buffalo chicken cheesesteak either stuffed to the brim on a great seeded roll! You also can’t go wrong with the classic broccoli bites which were overflowing with cheese! I didn’t catch any of the employees names tonight but you should be proud of the quality service...