I returned today and the pizza came out hot. My pickup order was ready about five minutes after the pickup time (which is completely acceptable to me) even though they were pretty busy. I'll chalk the previous experience as a fluke. I've bumped the rating up to five stars and this is now my favorite gluten free pizza I've had.

Original review:

Great food, not the best experience

I ordered the Monaco pizza gluten free and a gluten free smore brownie. I arrived five minutes before my scheduled pickup time. Was greeted promptly. After waiting for a few minutes they told me it would be out shortly and they were just waiting on the brownie. I ended up getting my food about fifteen minutes after my pickup time.

It was pretty obvious that the pizza was sitting on a counter the whole time too because it wasn't hot and was just slightly above room temperature. It tasted great though. Bursting with flavors on all ends - salty, sweet, spicy. It was also not a thin, cracker type crust that Columbus is unfortunately known for. I don't know the official moniker, but it's somewhere between a New York style and a thinner Sicilian. I was worried when I ordered that it was just a personal pizza but was about the size of a traditional medium, so I feel the price is slightly high, but not close to a premium price.

The brownie on the other hand seems slightly small in comparison to other desserts in the price range. It is absolutely delicious though and is now my favorite gluten free dessert I've ever had. It would be a no-brainer recommendation for anyone if it was $6. It should be noted that I believe it is traditionally not gluten free and there is no upcharge for them preparing it gluten free. I'll definitely be back.

As of right now I think Pizza House edges it out for my favorite gluten free pizza, but that will probably flip when I return if I get a warm/hot pizza.

I should also note that the servers were friendly and attentive.

I will update this review if I was glutened. (Edit: No allergy issues!)