Giant Slice Pizza — Restaurant in Corolla

Mixed Review: Great Service, While this establishment offers great value, my recent pizza order fell significantly short on toppings. I ordered a Large Supreme and a Hawaiian pizza, and both were noticeably sparse. Being the last customer, I'm unsure if they simply ran out, but it's crucial that orders aren't taken if there aren't enough ingredients to fulfill them properly. On a positive note, the staff were awesome! They generously offered me pepper flakes and Parmesan to go, which was a thoughtful gesture, even though I unfortunately forgot them on the counter. Despite the excellent service, the overall quality of the pizza due to the lack of toppings was quite disappointing.

Excellent Value and Service, but Pizza Quality Suffered

I found the value here to be excellent, and the staff provided awesome service. They kindly gave me pepper flakes and Parmesan to go, a testament to their helpfulness (my fault for leaving them behind!). However, the pizza quality was unfortunately subpar due to a severe lack of toppings. Both my Large Supreme and Hawaiian pizzas came with very few toppings, which was quite disappointing. If it was due to being the last customer and running out, perhaps orders shouldn't be accepted if all ingredients aren't available. The pizza itself...

Stopped in on a Saturday evening to pick up a couple pizzas. First time trying Giant Slice. Got one XL Cheese and one XL Specialty. Almost $40. Called ahead 20 mins out....were told ready in 20. Upon arrival we told the cashier we had ordered by phone and she asked our name. One other gentleman waiting. Employee said they'd let us know when pizzas were ready. 20 minutes later another employee asked if we were waiting. We gave our name again and......surprise, our pizzas were on the rack behind him. Where they'd been probably for 20 mins. No worries. But the pizza was really a HUGE disappointment. Honestly like a thick dry saltine (my wife said cardboard) with some toppings. Not very tasty. Won't be going there again. Major BUMMER pizza joint. Also, if you aren't local....be prepared to search for the place for 10 mins....

While on vacation we tried Giant Slice because we wanted to support a family owned business; however, our experience and the food were both very disappointing. I don’t often take time to write reviews, but because the pizza was so bad I felt it would be helpful to others. The first pizza delivered, after an hour and 15 min, looked horrible and was cold. Even the delivery person said it looked bad before I said anything. He tried to make it right by having another pizza delivered, but that took another hour - not exactly how we planned to spend our 4th of July evening. And, while the second one looked better and was warmer, it was not good. Just not good pizza and definitely nothing like New York Style. Frozen pizza is a better option. We ate very few slices and threw...