Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake — Restaurant in Crystal Lake

Place's clean. Very good first impression.

My pizza was ready on time. I scheduled to pick up my pizza @ 9p. Pizza's ready @ 9p.

Pizza's delicious!

I ordered the 2 1/2" stuffed pizza and my wife and I were not disappointed.

My wife and I looked at each other and pretty much had the same thought... "Am I hungry or is this pizza is just delicious?!"

I had 2 1/2 slices of the large pizza. My wife had 1 1/2.

I was hungry + the pizza's really good!

I ordered Cannoli too but didn't get to sample it. Maybe later... with milk.

If you haven't tried Nancy's yet, you should.

By the way, the large stuffed pizza I ordered with sausage, pepperoni, 1/2 black olives, easy onions, green peppers, and mushrooms cost me $41.48 with tax.

Be aware of the cost of the pizza. It's not Little Caesar's or Domino's or Papa John's.

I hope this helps you, future Nancy's...

Very disappointing! I ordered online and requested that they use their smooth pizza sauce for the stuffed pizza. I explicitly stated my family does not care for the chunky tomato sauce. If they were confused, I would have expected a call. Instead when my husband picked it up, the manager told him “I know your wife didn’t want the chunky sauce, buts that’s how we do it”. He then added “you won’t know the difference, it’s very good”! Well my family knows what they like, and the pizza was wasted! If they refuse to honor their customers requests, I would at least expect phone call to give me the choice of trying it their way! So much for”build your own pizza”....

At 5:49 we placed our order for delivery(never again since I live 5 minutes down the road) but we were not in a hurry to eat and were working on a house project, so a 2 hour delivery time was perfect. Well cut to 20 minutes past the time they said the food would be ready, we called and found out they were on their way...we didn't get our food for 30+ minutes after they left their location(again I'm 5 minutes away). Last time ordering from here, Luke warm at best pizza, my boys love it so they may order again, but I expected much better service than...