Casey's — Restaurant in Elkhorn

We ordered the new BBQ Pulled Pork Friday 08/02/24. They accidentally put jalapenos instead of pickles. It was so good! The pork was REAL pulled pork and so delicious and the jalapenos went perfectly with it! Let me tell, it was so good, we ordered another one today, 08/06/24, and I’m not a huge pizza person - though Casey’s is my pizza go to. This time we ordered the same pulled pork, but half with pickles and half with jalapenos. Personally, I think the pickle side was a no, but to each their own. Whatever you decide upon, jalapenos, pickles or neither, you must try this pizza!!!

Shout out to the manager!!!👋🏼. Thank...

I’m so disappointed to write this review but the last few months at this Casey’s on Market Street, the pizza has been terrible. Thrown together very quickly, cut completely unevenly and under cooked and thrown in the box so everything is a mess. This has happened four times!!! I tried to Grace them over and over again but this last time I was fully refunded and I will be using the Casey’s across town on Geneva street...

Overall, this Casey’s is one of the better convenience stops in town. The staff are usually upbeat, the store’s clean, and they keep things stocked pretty well, especially the pizza and breakfast items. It’s quick and reliable whether you’re fueling up or grabbing a bite before work.

Compared to most gas stations around here, this location runs smoother than most. Solid crew and...