U.S. Pizza Co Fayetteville — Restaurant in Fayetteville

I’ll start off by saying that my friends and I normally love this Fayetteville staple, but our experience last night will likely be our last.

We were seated by the door originally and it was a bit chilly, so we asked to be moved to a table in the back. The waiter said it was fine, but seemed to change his attitude toward us after the request. We weren’t the only ones to do this though.. another couple who was sat by the door was soon moved to the back as well, so it didn’t seem like an outlandish request at all.

We ordered waters for the table and a mimosa bucket. It took about twenty minutes or so to get the bucket, and it came with no juice. Just straight champagne. Our waiter was nowhere to be seen after that. He came back eventually with juice but no waters. We placed our order for an appetizer, pizza, and again for waters. I also let him know that my other friend would be joining us.

She arrived before our waters and our food. The next time we saw our waiter, he brought out our appetizer and pizza at the same time. We again asked for waters and also ranch when he asked if we needed anything. He took my friend’s order, and eventually came back with waters but no ranch.

We let it slide because who knows, maybe he was new since he was young? Eventually the manager came over to check on us, and started by saying, “looks like you guys could use a little more room on that table huh?”. I told her it was a small table but we were making it work. She asked how the service and food was. We told her the food was good, the service was okay, and that we’ve been waiting on water refills and ranch for a while now. She asked us who our server was, so we pointed him out to her. She then turned to us and said in an incredibly snarky tone, “well I ensure you he is really doing his best”.

Umm okay? You asked us and we answered, ma’am. It was a very weird interaction. One that we talked about for the rest of the night.

Anyway, my friend’s pizza came out and we asked for a box and our checks. We accepted at this point that refills and ranch weren’t gonna happen. Once we got our checks, we saw that we were charged $2 extra each for pineapple juice even though we got orange juice. We agreed that it wasn’t even worth the hassle of mentioning and changing it as it would likely add another twenty minutes to our stay, so we went ahead and paid the additional charge.

As we were leaving, we heard the table next to us (a family with two children) complaining about the service as well. I saw that they had no drinks or food on the table although they had been there for some time.

Who knows, maybe we just ended up with a bad server and manager for the night. We don’t plan on coming back anytime soon to find out whether this was an...

Yeah, it’s a cool spot and it’s been around forever, but we went for Father’s Day 2025—just a few days ago—and honestly, it was a letdown. The pizza wasn’t good, and every plate and cup had gunk on it, like leftover dishwater or crud from the sink. Nothing felt clean.

The atmosphere was pure chaos. Rock music blared from the kitchen while easy jazz played from the ceiling speakers—it clashed hard. TVs were on every wall, but I almost think the place would be better without them. It was just too much happening at once.

Visually, it felt slapped together. Power strips dangled from the walls, not even mounted—though mounting them wouldn’t fix the look either.

The only bright spot was our server. It was his first shift, and we were his first table. We were friendly, joked around with him, and didn’t complain—he was still upbeat and hadn’t been worn down by all the quick fixes and patch jobs yet. You could tell he was trying, and we appreciated that.

As for the owner or manager—I’m not sure which—she’s a regular at my job, and even she doesn’t have anything good to say about the place when...

Ok so let's go🍕 I gave US Pizza 🍕4 Star because of their salads 😍🥗 "ah-yum" 🥗yes they are just that fresh and delicious.🥗 Those 4 Stars also include our great waitress 🌟Sheryl. Before I really go in I must let you all know I was born and raised in Arkansas I LoVe my State and love it even more when we have good eats.💞 I have been eating US Pizza salads for over 23 years. Check this out I was visiting family in Fayetteville Arkansas and happened to be strolling down Dixon Street all up in Razorbacks Country 👐 "Woo Pig Sooie" Yooo! I spotted👀 US Pizza and couldn't wait to get back there the next day for my favorite salad. So my family been in the area for many years and didnt know it was there🙄 Wat!! But I got them hooked on the salads now, freshness and greatness in a to go box😜🥗 Now the wings 🤪 and the "Pizza" 🍕for me I bet they can really work on that some more....I will for sho be back my next visit for a salad and great customer...