Jersey Brothers Pizza & Pasta — Restaurant in Florida

Updated review:

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We came in as a family to sit down and enjoy dinner, and from the moment we walked through the door, we knew we’d found a gem. The staff greeted us with genuine smiles and made us feel right at home. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming — the kind of local spot that feels like it’s been part of the community for years.

We started with the fresh cheesy bread, and it was absolutely fantastic — hot, buttery, and perfectly golden, with just the right balance of garlic and cheese. Then came the pizza, and honestly, it blew us away. The crust had that perfect combination of crunch and chew, the sauce tasted fresh and flavorful, and the cheese was perfectly melted and stretchy. You can tell everything is made with real care and quality ingredients.

I’ve been eating pizza for over forty years, and I can honestly say this ranks in my top three pizzas of all time. It’s that good. The whole family loved it, and we left talking about how soon we could come back.

If you’re looking for a true neighborhood pizza and pasta spot with outstanding food, great service, and a family-friendly vibe, Jersey Brothers Pizza and Pasta should be at the top of your list.

We stopped by Jersey Brothers Pizza & Pasta around 2:00 PM and had a really good experience overall. The pizza was excellent — generous slices, great flavor, and very fair pricing. The lady who runs the place was super friendly and made us feel welcome. The only reason I can’t give 5 stars is that the pizza wasn’t quite as fresh as I’d hoped (but to be fair, we got there in the early afternoon). All in all, this will be a spot I’ll return to — highly...

This was our first time ordering from here. I called in an order for a Philly Cheesesteak Sub and a Meatball Parmesan Sub. 2 Sandwiches. I was told 30 minutes. I got there in 20 minutes. I paid for my order with CASH. I should have checked my receipt before I got home. They actually charged me a Service Charge ( I guess for giving them my business). This should be addressed. It’s called stealing. Credit or Debit cards are charged service fees by some companies, NOT CASH CUSTOMERS. SEE RECEIPT .So after waiting, and waiting, along with being told several times that it would be a couple more minutes ( several times ) Their 30 minutes quote ended up being 45 minutes for 2 Sub Sandwiches . Both ladies were friendly with their service, but perhaps add more time to your quotes. And extend the concerns to the kitchen. The Philly Cheesesteak was a bit salty, and lacking cheese. It had plenty of meat , although it was overcooked. The Meatball Parmesan had plenty of meat as well. And tasty meatballs. But I do like French and Italian bread much better than I do their Amoroso bread, the sauce could use a bit more flavor. The cheese was good. Again this was the very first time trying this establishment. They have drink coolers filled with bottled Great Value water and canned soda $$$. We might try them again,maybe. But perhaps we’d try their pizza instead. We’ll see. We want to support...

Being a native South Jersey couple, we are very picky about our pizzeria type food. I worked at many pizzerias in Jersey and Philly area for a good 20 years. We ordered their regular stromboli and a cheesesteak because we were to eager to just try one thing at a time. Both came out at the same time and the cheesesteak was just as hot as the Stromboli so I know it didn't sit around waiting for the stromboli to finish. The pizza sauce for the Stromboli was excellent, just enough sweetness that I could taste it, the exact way we like our sauce. It was loaded with cheese and toppings, they did not skimp at all. My husband and I both looked at each other and thought they've got to be losing money on this because it was only 13 bucks And it had to have more cheese in it than a large pie. The roll for the cheesesteak was excellent. That is the biggest issue for us in Florida is that nobody can make a good cheesesteak roll. You could taste that the cheese steakmeat wasn't a watered down frozen puck, it was definitely real shaved beef. Now that we live 5 minutes away from this awesome place I will be trying something different every week! Definitely a little slice of Jersey in Bradenton as their motto...