Generations Pie Company — Restaurant in Fortville

We had heard about Generations Pie Company, so we gave it a try this Thanksgiving. Never again. We were so disappointed. First, the man working at the Fortville location was rude when my husband picked up. The caramel apple pie was terrible. It was so watery, the crust was soft. The pumpkin seemed under cooked and had very little filling.. My family all said a grocery pie would have been better. Thank goodness I had made another dessert. That is what everyone ate. My dad who loves sweets, didn't even want the leftover pie. We...

I stopped in once and picked up a slice of sugar cream pie and some pie bites—my total was over $20, and I honestly walked out wondering what I had just paid for. The pie slice was extremely small, and the flavor didn’t live up to expectations (honestly, I think the frozen kind from Kroger might be better). The pie bites were overwhelmingly rich—so much so, they were hard to eat. I really wanted to like this place because I appreciate supporting local businesses, but this just wasn’t it for me. Not...

I bought two fruit pies from their business and they we're horrible, I know a good pie. They both taste like a can of fruit was used no juice or filling at all. Also what kind of crust is this! The packaging is what sells the pies. I don’t typically leave bad reviews but there is no hope for any of these desserts they sell. I come from a long line of chefs in my family and this was not good. For everyone who says they are good don’t...