East Coast Pizza — Restaurant in Garfield Heights

$71 later…. 2 pizzas 1 small shrimp and 1 medium deluxe with anchovies banana peppers extras cheese sausage and 1 lb of chicken wings delivered. I don’t mind paying for good food as I have been there before and really enjoyed the Supreme and wings but I was greatly disappointed as I had to really search to find the shrimp. I certainly didn’t taste any. It was nothing short of a glorified overpriced vegetable pizza. Although the deluxe was good it was no match for the pizza that I enjoyed on my first visit and when I did a mock order online with exactly what I ordered by phone, the price was noticeably lower online. Finally the wings were edible. Not a good as I remembered and the homemade honey sauce had a date of 5/3. Today is 9/7. My first visit was great so I believe that maybe they just had an off day so I’ll give them another try because I, myself, have had them as well. I’ll let you know how it goes.

27 yrs ago I was making and delivering pizzas for A Touch of Italy in Shaker Heights for Mike. I am accustomed to real authentic homemade pizza and have no problem paying for it. Neither of the pizzas were great in my opinion of which I am entitled to. As a business owner you should respect that opinion whether you agree with it or not. You had an off day. If anyone wants really good pizza try A touch of Italy in Shaker Heights. The food is great and management has better people skills. I will drive farther and pay more but it’s worth it. Lastly, please don’t prejudge what you think I can afford. God blessed me abundantly with a great job that affords me the opportunity to splurge on demand. $71 is worth a good meal. You came up short. Consider...

Barely better than Tiffany's but that isn't saying much. Tons of grease and pretty flavorless. Literally seasoned it myself. Better off going with pizza hut or just make your own. Why do these places insist on not putting a lot of toppings on their product? Load it up! Stop being so greedy!

Edit 6-5-22

Wow that was a quick response. 7 spices? What did you do just put 7 tiny pinches in there to save on cost? No there is nothing wrong with my tastebuds but even if there was two other non smoking adults and 3 kids wanted nothing to do with your pizza after the other night. Your delivery driver was nice though! So...that's something right? Three decades of making sauce is impressive! I wonder if the same love and care has been kept up since all them years ago? I guess it would be impossible to tell if this was just a fluke or if we all have damaged tastebuds. Such a quick response though. Passive aggressive or not and on a Sunday as well. Figured you all would be a bit busy over there making flavorless pizzas instead of replying to Google reviews. Also nothing wrong with a little competition. Even if you don't see them as that...you probably should. Might make you want to try harder in the future. I also like how you never denied the lack of...

Unfortunately I had to change my ratings from 5 stars to 1. I was very disappointed when I ordered pizza from here this past Thursday 7/31/25. The pizza dough actually tasted stale and there was not enough sauce on the pizza. Over all this pizza was terribly nasty. In the past when I ordered pizza from here, it was always delicious and always tasted fresh. I managed to eat two slices and just threw the rest in the trash. This was my favorite pizza spot too. Please use fresh products/ingredients and stop trying to save money by using old pizza dough. Your prices are a bit more expensive for your pan sizes, then most pizza restaurants in the area, which I thought was OK, because your pizza was ALWAYS delicious and ALWAYS tasted fresh, and I felt it was worth every penny. PLEASE...