Poseidon’s Italian Kitchen — Restaurant in Gloucester

After change in ownership I have given this establishment multiple chances to prove itself to me. But every time I get food I am always left extremely disappointed and upset that I wasted money on this place. I’ve gotten pizza multiple times, every time it’s soaked in grease because they use cheddar cheese. I tried the Mexican once a quesadilla It made me extremely nauseous afterwords. Today was kind of the last stand before I decided it was time to say something. I ordered a Tuna with pickles a staple in Gloucester sub shops, not only was it astronomically expensive $17 for a tuna sub it was tuna salad which is just more filler than tuna. I’m so sad that this establishment has failed in every category it tries to fall in. If I want to pay a lot for food I’ll go to the causeway where at least there I can guarantee that I will get a large amount of food for my dollar. Or if I want a sub go to The new waterfront cafe where I know the food and service is consistently good. To the owners of Poseidon’s, you’re trying to fit into too many boxes and it just feels like it’s hurting you. As a suggestion I’d focus on improving your food and earning your astronomical pricing. It simply feels like I’m being robbed every time I order from your establishment and I can’t justify coming...

Got the Godfather sub, Chicken cutlet, basil, tomatoes, mayo, balsamic vinegar, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella...14.99 I was expecting this to be a big sub... It was tiny... There was hardly any chicken cutlet in it...most of it was chopped tomatoes, small amount of basil ..There was no roasted peppers and the fresh mozzarella was very scarce .... My son ate it in less then 10 min!!! He was starved because delivery took too long...ordered at 8:15 arrived at 9:23...and it's literally around the corner from me??? Empanadas...2 chicken 1 beef...again very tiny...and $4.99 a piece ???? I get Empanadas from Salem mass for 2.99 and they are huge,!!! Also they packed tomatoes sauce inside the container with the Empanadas and the lid was off and the tomato e sauce spilled all over the entire Empanadas so they were soaking wet!!! Dinner was ruined...$42.00 and delivery charge and tip..$48.00. And now I have to cook something else for my son because he's still hungry!!! If your going to charge $15.00 for a sub it should be very substantial...!!! I really like your pizza , I think you have the best pizza in town but it's way too expensive and I only order it once in a while, every other month but after tonight's food I think I won't be...

I hate to be leaving a one star on review on my ex-favorite pizza restaurant. Ordering from here used to be a source of pride, to let my friend’s experience the pizza which I confidently used to call the best on the north shore. I wept real tears when I had to grapple with the fact my future friends won’t ever taste the old Poseidons pizza.

Their Poseidons adventure had to have been the most delicious pizza ever made. The new menu has it gone, and their new pizza style is very disappointing. I don’t like making reviews, but I really want to know if this place is under new management? Or has been taken over by another franchise.

paid forty dollars for a large pizza and a side of onion rings BECAUSE I loved their pizza enough to pay that price without question. I genuinely feel scammed right now with how disappointing the new pizza is.

As a customer for years I can’t say I’ll be ordering from here anymore. At one point I was actually prepared to walk through a blizzard to get my pizza from here. After the new menu change, I’m deeply sad to say I don’t feel that...