Papa Johns Pizza — Restaurant in Greeley

Very disappointed with this delivery order. For starters, we wanted to try out the NY style pizza (we both lived in the tri-state area and wanted to see how PJ measured up), but we received what seems like a regular pan pizza. It wasn't thin enough a crust and did not fold... but there's another potential reason for that: our pizza was left on the door step without a knock or doorbell ring (which i specified in the notes); we have a dog that didn't even look up or do his usual alert when someone approaches the door. The pizza sat on our doormat long enough to get cold, for the cheese to be stiff, and the garlic sauce became more solidified.

It looks great, and would have been decent (albeit, an incorrect order) if it wasn't cold.

Also, the NY style pizza is advertised for $13 online, we did 3 toppings, added 2 garlic sauce (60 cents each) and it totaled to $28.15 for one pizza after taxes, fees, and tip. We haven't ordered from PJ in a long while, and after this experience, I can't think of a reason why we would...

Man this is a tough one for me. My family used to order here all the time. The food was always fresh, and the customer service was fantastic. One night I ordered a pizza for the family and unfortunately found a hair baked into my pizza slice. Thankfully I took the slice instead of one of my kiddos, but regardless it kinda ruined Papa John's pizza for me. When I explained the situation they only offered a remake, which I denied and asked for wings because I wasn't really in a pizza mood afterwards. I got my 8 wings with a half apology. I pretty much got told they don't know how that's possible because they wear hats and one employee was bald. Situation sucks, but honestly I've had dang good pizza from here besides that one experience! Please note the store is also super clean, and the people...

They suck! We found a add that said 2 pizzas + dessert or 2 large pizzas for $12.99 and one guy said he saw it on there eeb site but that it didnt show up in there system. Then once you backed out and go back in it changed to a new spacial but therr manager refused to honor the deal that we found! Do not go here as they will screw you for more money! I even have a screenshot and took it to them and still the manager refused to honor the deal! This place is running a scam, i even called the police and they even saw the deal they refused to honor! Who would want to do business with someone like this! I will be posting these photos i have all over the internet, if i could post them...