Starlight Diner - Hanover, PA
Starlight Diner - Hanover, PA things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
July 2023 Stopped in for a BLT. Seated quickly, great service, food came quickly. Would have been a very pleasant experience.. except; Our poor server was vacuuming PLUS taking care of her tables. One table needed something do she laid the vacuum down. The shift manager (owner?) screamed at her, berating her in front of all the customers, threatening to dock her pay, and generally being way over the top for laying a vacuum down. If that was the manager, SHE needs fired. If the owner, a course on personnel interactions. There's never a reason to do something like that in front of customers, nor to scream over a minor offense. Wait staff are people, too. Treat them with respect. ±++++++++++++++++++++ Aug 2022 Went back on a whim. Much better service, food was fair. Laci our server was on point. Only flaw was the host, who acted like we were all bothering him when checking out, so attitude is still a problem for some. Well try it again however. *********** 2021 . Been a few years since I've eaten here. Tonite is probably the last. Food was mediocre at best. The service... I can't decide if the staff was insolent, indifferent, or lazy. There were at least 4 wait staff and maybe 8 tables with customers. 10 minutes to place our order, and 15 for our check. Waitress never did come back to collect it. Finally left cash and too much tip. Regulars seemed to get all the attention, at least when staff wasn't talking and flirting with each other. Do yourself a favor, go to Sheetz. Better food and faster service.
D.B. FrankD.B. Frank
00
Not a good experience. My wife and I went there today for breakfast. Had morning wait. We expected that. Not a big deal. We got to our table know what we wanted already. Server came and ask about coffee which we said yes, plus some waters. We informed her that we were ready to order. We ordered a western omelette with home fries and wheat toast, plus some sausage links. We told her that we were just gonna share. Our food arrived, and we were ready for some more coffee. She told us when she brought our food out that she had gotten us an extra plate. We waited a good ten minutes before she finally came around with refills. We mentioned to her that we hadn’t received out sausages yet. She said that she would get them. Not sure what was on our plate, so I sat it on the table. You can try and figure it out in the photo. We really have no clue. The server even asked us what it was. She thought it was a dried sausage. Makes it more disgusting because we didn’t get our sausage until ten to fifteen minutes later. Then we get our bill. That’s when we learned that we were charge $.75 for the extra plate. Seriously!! I know it’s not much, but that’s not the point. Just trying to make an extra buck. I can tell you that we will not be going back to this place again.
S LardoS Lardo
00
Came here to eat for the first time inside the building… We’ve gotten take out here before many times but I myself never went inside. I went with the usual, chicken tenders and fries. Can’t really go wrong. Sometimes they are really good here, other times they are ok. Seems as if they come from different distributors. Last night, they were not the really good ones. First time trying the chicken sandwich. It was very, very chewy. I ended up having to share mine with my son. Sandwich- I forget what he got, I think it was a Rueben. He said it tasted like a Rueben should. Everyone loved the bacon cheese fries. Mozzarella sticks came out Luke warm, or else they would have been better. Dessert was all meh. I was sooo excited for dessert, especially after sharing my meal. Highly disappointed. They were all VERY sweet. I’m a sweet lover, it was too much. They also tasted like they were a few days old. I’d definitely come back. Food was very cheap. We got all of this for around $63. I’d just suggest not getting the chicken sandwich, or the dessert.
Ashley HAshley H
00
Nearby Attractions Of Starlight Diner - Hanover, PA
North Hanover Mall
Hobby Lobby
North Point Plaza Shopping Center
Gateway Hanover Shopping Center
Clearview Shopping Center
Grocery Outlet
Black Rose Antiques & Collectibles
Garrick Jewelers
sweetFrog Premium Frozen Yogurt
Stonegate Square Shopping Center

North Hanover Mall
3.5
(1.2K)Click for details

Hobby Lobby
4.5
(772)Click for details

North Point Plaza Shopping Center
4.2
(357)Click for details

Gateway Hanover Shopping Center
4.3
(355)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Starlight Diner - Hanover, PA
Famous Hot Weiner North Inc
Bay City Seafood Restaurant
Plaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant · Hanover
Bob's Beer & Soda
Jerry & Sal’s Pizza
Hoss's Steak & Sea House
Infinito's Pizza Buffet
El Agave Market Restaurant
Texas Roadhouse
Aki

Famous Hot Weiner North Inc
4.4
(735)Click for details

Bay City Seafood Restaurant
4.1
(705)$$
Click for details

Plaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant · Hanover
4.7
(260)Click for details

Bob's Beer & Soda
4.8
(254)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
1177 Carlisle St, Hanover, PA 17331, United States
Map
Phone
+1 717-698-1514
Call
Website
starlightdinerhanover.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.3
(1.1K reviews)
Ratings & Description
attractions: North Hanover Mall, Hobby Lobby, North Point Plaza Shopping Center, Gateway Hanover Shopping Center, Clearview Shopping Center, Grocery Outlet, Black Rose Antiques & Collectibles, Garrick Jewelers, sweetFrog Premium Frozen Yogurt, Stonegate Square Shopping Center, restaurants: Famous Hot Weiner North Inc, Bay City Seafood Restaurant, Plaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant · Hanover, Bob's Beer & Soda, Jerry & Sal’s Pizza, Hoss's Steak & Sea House, Infinito's Pizza Buffet, El Agave Market Restaurant, Texas Roadhouse, Aki
