Sully's Grill at Sullivan Hardware & Garden — Restaurant in Indianapolis

Husband had the brisket sandwich, which was amazing. I just wish it had enough brisket to cover the bun... but the salad as the side can be skipped. Arugula .. yuck clearly nothing but arugula thrown on the plate... chef could have been a little more creative. I had a Thai salad made with spaghetti squash with cabbage mixed in.... good, but nothing to write home about

But the main reason they got a 2 star was because from the moment we walked in, we felt like we were not welcome. Went to sit down.. headed outside of course server said that area is closed...ok then went to sit in the dining area and again she said we are getting ready to set up for a private party so you will only have a short time to sit in this area. Ok... then I asked what time do you close?. I'm thinking, Well, maybe they close at like 4 or so.. she said open till 8. Ok, we drove an hour and can't sit on patio cant sit in the dining room. We deal with it. Both hubby and I said wow not off to a good start it was nothing like what we expected. Server.... a little salty and short like she had better places to be. We ordered... husband had a question about an appetizer, the peppers.. she answered his question as if she was scolding him for not knowing... it was weird.. we ordered.. then another family came. Same thing... went to sit in the dining room, and they got the same rude response. No, welcome to sullys it was just... that section is closed for a private party... So they came out and sat in seating in the hardware area. I heard her order soup and salad... out of soup.. said the server.. ok, you have like 6 things on the menu. It's 3 o'clock, and u are out of stuff already. I had ordered soup and salad, so I guess I got the last cup.

It was gross no flavor, so she was lucky, haha. anyway, dont bother with sullys unless u like a rude waitress and a menu that isn't available.. oh, she came out and erased the dessert board. She said they were out of desserts.. WoW.. bad experience. OVER $50 for a plate of arugala, brisket sandwich which i think was 3 small pieces of meat and spaghetti squash with vinegar and 4 cashews and the bottom of the pan...

Small, but creative and outstanding menu. Who would have thought that eating at the hardware store would be a thing? And a really good thing, at that!

There are always choices for meat eaters, vegetarians and vegans. I have been here at least 6 times in the past month - four times for lunch and twice for dinner. The menu is the same for each meal, but there are specials each day that are not on the menu. Desserts are also incredible.

The menu changes seasonally, so I don't want to mention specific items in case they are not available when you go. All I can say is that I've had multiple appetizers, salads and sandwiches and I have only eaten one thing that I felt was NOT outstanding. It was merely really good.

Some may find it pricey, but for the freshness of the ingredients and the creative preparation, I happen to think it's a great deal. You can buy similar food elsewhere for less money, but it's not going to be made with this level of expertise...

I had the pleasure of attending a wine dinner at Sully's restaurant and I must say, it was an absolutely delightful experience. The main course of rack of lamb was cooked to perfection - tender, juicy, and full of flavor. But the real star of the show was the dessert, a light crusted raspberry and chocolate dish that was simply divine. It was the perfect ending to a fantastic meal.

The French-inspired menu was expertly paired with a selection of wines that complemented each dish beautifully. I had the opportunity to try a variety of wines throughout the evening, each one enhancing the flavors of the food in a unique way.

Overall, I would give Sully's restaurant a perfect 10/10 rating. The food was delicious, the wine selection was superb, and the atmosphere was elegant and inviting. I would highly recommend Sully's to anyone looking for a memorable...