Hill & Holler — Restaurant in Lewisburg

June 2022 in Lewisburg on business and excited to give Hill & Holler a try. When we arrived, it wasn't very busy so we took advantage of great weather to eat on the patio. Service seemed a bit slow but no problems initially. We ordered a small caesar salad, half order of wings and a pizza with chicken added. Our pizza came out first after half an hour or so, but without the chicken. Our waiter assured us the salad and wings were on their way. 45 minutes later, after asking again... still no salad or wings. Looking around us, other tables appeared to have similar issues. The waiter was practically non-existent, ignoring us as he went by and avoiding eye contact. We finally got wings (a dozen in place of the half dozen, which was nice) but still no salad. At that point it had been well over 90 minutes, we told them to forget the salad and please make sure the pizza was correct on the check since it did not come out with the meat added. In the middle this, the people at the table next to us started a conversation, having some of the same issues. The service was so bad, they were actually laughing and counting how many times the waiter walked by ignoring requests for refills, avoiding eye contact, etc. We asked a different waiter for a refill and received a very short 'tell your waiter'... at which point we just got up and went to the bar for refills. We decided to chalk this up to a bad experience and not let it ruin our day. We noted no less than 5 employees serving tables outside, these employees were also waiting on inside tables. A huge pile of dirty dishes sat on large high top nearby. Our check came out completely wrong with the salad and add on meat still on the check. We asked the waiter to correct it, 17 minutes later... yes, we timed it for fun... he still hadn't returned. So, one of our party went in to find a manager... no luck. We ended up just correcting the bill and leaving cash on the table. The good: The food that did come out was delicious even though nothing about the order was correct. The bad: None of the food came out as ordered, the service was the worst I've ever experienced, and it took well over 2 hours to get pizza and wings. No clue what ever happened to that salad. Based on this experience, I recommend you skip Hill & Holler and try one of the other superb restaurants...

I had heard that Hill and Holler was a fantastic experience. Unfortunately that was not my experience.

Not only did we receive the wrong food it took so long to get, I will say the sesame soy wings were the best part of the lunch. The calzone we ordered a spinach and feta with added ingredients came out as something else off the menu, they did offer to fix this or take it off the bill. I told them not to worry about it and we would just try it. We were on a bit of a schedule and needed to hurry.

The food

Garlic wings, meh.... I didn't thing the garlic was good. It did not combine well in my opinion with the smoked wings.

Sesame Soy wings were amazing and if I was ever willing to go back I would order them again.

The wrong calzone was disappointing. The stuffing was minimal and you couldn't really enjoy the flavor around the breading the sauce was bland.

We received the bill, it was 39 bucks I gave my card and the waitress charged us for another tables ticket. 50 bucks.........

We attempt to get it fixed after waiting another ten minutes. I finally just said give me my card just keep the 11 buck for a tip... I then left, we were already running late. As my wife and I are getting in to the car the manager comes out claiming we were dine and dashing and that he was calling the cops...... Even took a photo of our license plate. We went back inside and had to pay for our ticket too on top of the one the billed to us erroneously. I now have a charge for both meals on my act. I won't get a refund until sometime next week thanks to their idiocy and the holiday. Not only was the service and food bad, but then they treated my wife and I like criminals for their incompence.

I wouldn't have bothered with a review prior to the way they treated my wife and I over their own mistakes.

I'm a big believer in supporting local but I will never support them after the way they treated us.

To top that all off they made us so late that we had to cancel our appointment.

Thanks for a s* experience...

I was so excited to come here. I've heard. I bought it and was in the area when I got to the restaurant. It was up 15 after 11 and the doors were closed and locked on a Saturday. So I pulled up the Google listing, and it said they were supposed to be open. I called the restaurant and they said they were open, and I told them their doors were laughed. So they opened the doors and I came in talk to uh the host and some of the servers and uh uh got an idea about their menu, I told them that I had gone to italy last year and took a day would fire pizza making training how excited I was to try their pizza.

I used to talk to a manager to see if maybe they would consider adding July to to the menu and to, uh, still explain that nowhere on the signage. Does it say wood fire Pizza oven? Uh, uh, so the gentleman that came over, Charlie was less than pleasant and seemed very uh. Unfriendly. I wanted to explain to him that my Pizza. It was good and I asked him to have a seat because I didn't want him to stand over me. While I had this conversation, he refused to sit with me. So, um is so additionally. The Pizza saucewas cold when it came to my table. So I explained that to him, and he just seemed very argumentative, anything that I wanted to chat with him about. He took exception to and was aggressive in his Responses in his posture. Almost to the point of being hostile, so I think they have great potential, not sure what's going on with the management, or why they didn't unlock the door today. We'll see I did ask for the owner's name and asked the manager if he could write that down for me and he told me no, that he...