Yorktown Bagels & Bialys — Restaurant in Manalapan Township

Didn’t even eat my bagel.

1)There were two women at the counter. One took my order and the other one was texting on her phone with gloves on (I’m assuming from making bagels) after the other lady took our order it was only after when I went to pay did I realized she was too wearing the same gloves she used to make our bagels as she did to take the money out of my hands AND that glove was DISGUSTING, it was yellow-green on the finger tips. This glove has obviously been used for a veryyyy long time. By this point she already had my money in her hands.

2. The place looked so old and dirty, lights were dim. It looks like this place hasn’t been cleaned in years.

3. They DO NOT have a grill or serve any meats

4. Cash only

Never going back. I was new in town and saw this place had the best ratings but I’m really not sure why. I wish I didn’t go and waste my money. Bagels went right...

I’m going to give 5 stars because I love Yorktown bagels. But we have a serious issue now. This place is an institution and recent taken over by bagel talk. So far the bagels have seem to relatively remain the same which is great. However then staple tuna and lite tuna is long gone. It’s crucial that they try to replicate what existed. Bagel Talk is good. But let’s be honest. Yorktown bagel is something of legends and one of the most iconic bagel establishments in the world. Bagel talk owners please check up and make sure the spreads are true to tradition. Many people very angry. Also remove the cannoli bagels, this is very silly and is an embarrassing edition that ruins your credibility.

Ps. make sure the bialys are also true to Yorktown. Not true to bagel talk. Stay true to the ingredient providers and recipes.

Sincerely, Assistant to the...

I don’t normally post reviews but I really feel compelled to about this place. I am used to getting high quality bagels from north nj. When I came down here I was looking for a quality place again, and this is it! The bagels are baked and fluffy. Crunchy on outside and soft on inside. The lox bagel particularly is phenomenal, lox slices are generously given and pilled high with tomato capers and onions. You really feel like you get your moneys worth. If you are looking for a staple bagel place in central Jersey you must give this one a try. Best bagels around and...