Lighthouse Strollo's Homemade Italian Ice — Restaurant in Middletown Township

Okay ice cream and Italian ice, and if I'm being nice - okay service. One of the help tried to charge me $14 for a small sundae (which btw, this constitutes ice cream and hot fudge by their standards) and large ice cream with 1 topping (in dish), didn't even catch her own error until I balked, and then she told me it was $10, when I corrected her and said it's actually $9.50 (and this was her math W/a calculator). Anna's was by far better in both. Plus, she had a great menu. Lighthouse's menu is sparse, to...

• strawberry soft ice cream - i actually prefer hard ice cream although this was surprisingly good. i don’t like excessive fruit drizzles but the strawberry wasn’t too sweet or artificial flavored. • lemon italian ice - suuuuuuper sour. very bright and refreshing. if you’re familiar with del’s lemonade, then this is a way better version.

notes they close late which is perfect because i was craving dessert after a concert....

Italian ice soft serve is the only way to describe this ice. It was very good just wish there were more flavors to choose from. But the staff was very friendly and cheerfully helpful. It's clean and there are tables with umbrellas to sit at. The small of plenty big and I don't know what a medium or large looks like but you could definitely share one unless you have a large appetite. I'd go back and recommend...