Middletown Creamery — Restaurant in Middletown

This charming family-owned ice cream shop is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered in Middletown Delaware. From Walking in, you are greeted with the sweet scent of ice cream and a cheerful atmosphere that instantly puts a smile on your face.

The menu boasts a delightful array of flavors, from classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to unique creations like motor oil and my favorite strawberry cheesecake.

What truly sets this ice cream shop apart is the warm hospitality of the family who runs it. They treat every customer like a cherished guest, taking the time to recommend flavors and share the stories and connect with the people. It's a place where you feel like part of the family from the moment you step inside.

Whether you're looking for a refreshing treat on a hot summer day or a cozy indulgence in the winter months, this family-owned ice cream shop is a must-visit. It's a place where memories are made, flavors are savored, and happiness is served in every scoop. A true treasure in the community, this shop is sure to become a beloved favorite for families and friends alike, and they have pup cups which my dog loved.

Keep up the good...

Two people who ate from here had gotten food poisoning. First time it happened was when they opened and the second was last week. Don’t want to knock down family owned businesses but they are a serious health risk.

Response- When those same two people pass out from eating the ice cream then it is more than just a dairy problem going on. One of the customers noticed that the server would scoop off the top and dump down the drain and the texture is different from the ice cream at cowgirl creamery (which is the same ice cream you serve). I’m sure there are others out there who have experience the same thing but have yet to say something, not knowing it stemmed from your shop. Everyone in the store was kind but it doesn’t excuse the nonchalant response and lack of concern for health...

Salted caramel was genuinely rancid. sample tasted good but as I actually ate it, was more of a salt ice cream. I had to throw it away. they have a young girl working in the front, obviously I won’t make any assumptions, but she looks really young. Like 12 or something. also she was there by herself, while another employee, I’m assuming the owner, was there, not attending to the other customer. I think there’s a lot of potential with this place though. It seems very clean and put together. Some of the flavors of ice cream could definitely be better, and there should be more active employees. Other than that, a...