Papa Johns Pizza — Restaurant in Middletown

I'm giving this location a 5 star only because of the level of service I received when I picked up my order. The poor young guy l, trying to run the ENTIRE STORE ALONE SINCE 9AM, was doing an exceptional job of keeping it together!!!! Where is his help???

I much prefer the Kent Island location as their food and service are ALWAYS right on point. Unfortunately, due to traffic issues on a Sunday and my work location, it was closer to go to here..

I order 3 pizzas. With the exception of the works, the others were very good. The works pizza was very sparsely covered with toppings, definitely not compared to KI. The crust also seemed a little under baked?

The boneless wings are not that bad, just the quality of the actual chicken is poor. The boneless wings are essentially chicken nuggets/bites tossed in a flavor.

The cheesy bread and bread sticks were s hit. Although I've seen many reviews, give the plain bread sticks a bad review, they have always been my families favorite. Dunked in their marinara sauce - super yummy per the family!!

I highly recommend using their app. They have greats deals and you can never go wrong with the $6.99 deal for 2+ items!!! . I will say, I was rather upset to see that this location charges $3 to upgrade to a large pizza but KI location only charges $1 for same upgrade??? That's crazy.

I hope that the Management actually looks at these reviews. Although I'm sorry to say I didget his name, the STELLAR GUY deserves a lot more than just help. He deserves a bonus for yesterday 8/4!! I'm it weren't for him, the store would have not have been open costing them customers...

My fifth grader was given a 40% off coupon by his teacher and he was excited and asked me to go to Papa Johns. I was told a medium pizza after using the coupon was $16.57 with a soda so the original price of a medium stuffed crust pepperoni pizza's original prize would have been $30. The signed above said $15 she said that is the sale price and online was listed $13.99. I was given a non-itemized receipt which just said Batch ID 775 $16.57. Did not know what I was charged for if the coupon was taken off. When I talked to the lady, Christina??, she was rude. Even though she had no control over the price, she needs to ring up with items showing clearly and not quoting the wrong price. She should not tell me the prices that are different from the sign and internet. When I told her it cause the inconvenience of checking my bank account to get the refund in a few days, she was rude and told me that I caused the inconvenience for them instead of an apology for making up a receipt. Rude!!! There are a lot of pizza places on...

I didn't order pizza, which explains why my order was not wrong, but I ordered pizza a couple days ago at around 2:30... I do have some complaints, however: 1.) When I first ordered for delivery, for about 45 minutes, it showed up as "ESTIMATED DELIVERY TIME: NOT AVAILABLE", so I tried calling but apparently they were "closed" despite the delivery time being between the time I ordered. 2.) After 45 minutes of waiting for the delivery time to show up, it showed as 36 minutes approximately for delivery. TELL ME WHY IT TOOK THEM OVER AN HOUR TO DELIVER MY FOOD. I don't even live that far from the delivery place. 3.) I ordered some jalepeno rolls without meat, and I didn't get meat luckily, the food was O.K. quality, BUT I suggest adding more cream cheese to your rolls, they tasted kinda dry.

Overall O.K. this time compared to previous experiences, but please take a faster time...