wish upon a pastry — Restaurant in Midland Park

If I could give more stars I would! Found out about this amazing pastry shop on Instagram when it popped up in my feed. Since I'm a Disney fanatic since the early 70's lol I had to go check it out. I bought three cookies, two macarons, a Mickey Rice Krispie treat and a Mickey chocolate covered marshmallow....they also have candles that have park scents and ice cream which I'm definitely buying next time I go which will most likely be next week lol. So the first thing I tried was a macaron. I'll first say I'm not normally a fan of macarons. The few places I've gotten them from (including in the France Pavilion in Epcot) they've always been really dry and I've always wondered why do people like these so much? Lol. I normally wouldn't have bought any but they have a POG juice flavor one and I had to try it (also got a Grey Stuff one). Let me tell you....finally! These were great! Not dry at all! Great flavor and texture. Definitely didn't fall apart in my hand as I tried to eat it! I'll definitely get more next time but honestly will probably stick to not buying macarons anywhere else. Lol. Next up I tried the cookies. So a lot of times cookies that are frosted/decorated like this don't taste great. That's been my experience anyway. Omg. Not at all the case with these!! They have great flavor, again not dry and crumbly and they're not sugary sweet either, just sweet enough. The Rice Krispie treat and the chocolate covered marshmallow were both yummy as well but the stand outs of what I got were the macaroons and the cookies! Those cookies! I'm trying to ration out the three I bought so I don't have all three eaten before I go back! The owners were really friendly too and answered any questions I had and also told me everything was handmade by them (even the candles!) I drove 30 mins to get there and it was totally worth it. I know they do custom cakes as well which look fantastic from what I've seen. You can also order from their website. Go get your cookies!!! You won't be disappointed! You might even get addicted like me! Lol. When you can't get to the parks this is the perfect substitute to hold you over. I actually was supposed to be in WDW for my bday but had to cancel the trip so I went to Wish Upon a Pastry because I thought I deserved some treats on my...

This is my new favorite bakery! I had a custom cookie order done with Winnie the Pooh, Stitch, Cinderella’s Castle, Snow White, Spaceship Earth, Mickey Cupcake, Kermit the Frog, etc., and they were all delicious! The designs were well done and exceeded my expectations. I even added a few more to my order when I went to pick them up since they were so good! It was Star Wars weekend, so Darth Vader and the Mandalorian were delicious additions. The Mice Krispies were just like the ones in Magic Kingdom; the M&M topping was a perfect choice! The chocolate was fresh and rich as well. I had two of the Yoda macaroons for May 4, and their buttercream flavor was delicious and smooth; I would definitely order them again. They also had Ronto Wraps to celebrate May 4, which were the delicious savory treat of the day! I felt like I was in Hollywood Studios again, which is always a great feeling! I definitely recommend that everyone visit here and try their abundance of delicious treats. Whether you get a sugar cookie, macaroon, rice krispie or specialty item, you’re going to love it! They also have Park Scented Candles in store based off rides and resorts. I bought the Pirates Water one from the Pirates of the Carribbean ride! I can’t wait to come back for more treats and...

There’s not enough words to describe how delicious these treats are and how much I love this bakery! I have ordered cookies from wish upon a pastry several times now, and I could not be happier every time I pick up a new order! Michelle is so wonderful and makes the ordering process so easy, she always listens to my ideas and somehow translates that into beautiful cookies! Everyone always raves about how perfect they are, and the beauty is only surpassed by how yummy these treats taste!

The bakery itself is amazing, and while I’ve only pre-ordered cookies before, I usually always try something new when I stop in. We’ve tried several different homemade ice cream flavors- my son is a huge fan of the cotton candy and my fave is the toasted coconut! The cupcakes and cream puffs are also incredible. There’s always single cookies (usually Disney themed!) in the front and we always grab a few of those too!

Michelle and Torre are so kind, attentive to detail, and the love they put into their creations really shows. I can’t wait for my next event so I can...