Antolino's Pizza — Restaurant in Mifflin Township

I hate to be that guy, but today I have to be that guy, sigh. So this was my second time here. I enjoyed the first pizza I got, which was a pepperoni and sausage pizza. So I decided to come back for a second time. My next visit wasn't as good as the first; as a matter of fact, it was a nightmare.

On my second visit to the establishment, I tried to place a call over the phone. I called four times, but there was no answer, so I figure they must've been busy with calls. I pulled up into the parking lot in front of the shop and tried to call them. I noticed the person who was supposed to take the calls wasn't answering the phone; instead, she talked to the other two workers, but that's not where the nightmare began. I get out of my car and go inside, and placed the order.

Upon receiving my order, I go home for family pizza night. We are eating and watching movies when all of a sudden, I feel something in my throat. I thought maybe I didn't chew one of the toppings thoroughly. When I further investigated what the unknown morsel was, I was grossed out. It was an acrylic nail. The rest of the family stopped eating their pizza after this occurred. I called the place at 9:36 pm to share the horror story with them. I was instructed to come in the following day and see the owner.

When I got there, before I could introduce myself and get through the door, the owner asked, "You had two medium pizzas?" I said yes. He asked me how much I paid. I said I'm not sure; I didn't have my receipt on hand. He then tells me, based on the toppings I got, that it'll be about $25, but it's a little less than that, but I'll just give you $25. I said okay, and waited for some type of sincere apology. I got my $25 but no apology nor explanation of how the nail could have got into my pizza, literally in and out in one minute. What I'm most upset about, aside from no apology, is that I have a three-year-old son that loves pizza. I kept imagining if he had...

Antolino's is quite literally in an abandoned strip mall that has a psychic and a church, right past the intersection of Westerville Rd. and Morse.

The waiting area in the pizza place is in bad shape, looks run down, much like the rest of the strip mall. Employees were super friendly though and they had several pizza ovens and a large prep area.

They run a special, 2 large 1 topping pizzas for $22. Ordered a large mushroom, a large pepperoni, onion, and sausage (only $2 extra for the 2 toppings), a quart salad with Italian dressing, garlic bread with cheese, and an Italian sub. All of that was only $39, so the price was absolutely fantastic.

Pizza style is typical Ohio/Midwest style - thin crust, square cut. Dough, cheese, and toppings were all good, sauce was a bit bland though. Italian sub was pretty good, same with the garlic bread and salad.

Overall it's a decent pie, not the best but definitely good, especially for the price point.

I'd rank it right around Massey's in quality but definitely not as good as Terita's or Tommy's.

I give the pizza a 4.4 and the sides a 4.5. Google doesn't allow decimal reviews, so due to the excellent price and friendly staff I decided to...

Since 1980s till Bobby left the pizza was the best it was a 5 star now that Bobby has left no one cares what they serve. We have been customers since the 80s. Last month we ordered a pizza and was told we would get it in a hour well Iwaited a hour and a half when the pizza didnt arrive I called was told well we got busy and your pizza is just coming out of the oven we will give you a free 2 liter for your troubles still had to wait another half hour for the pizza the pizza came was cold and burnt. So I said well with the pandemic ok I'll let it go ordered last night got the pizza in about an hour and opened it and burnt again didnt call cause I would have just got a free 2 liter not worth it. To bad Bobby cant come back cause I know for a fact he would have never let them 2 pizzas out of that store.The company has gone down hill I think I will be finding somewhere else and telling everyone that will...