Peel Pizza Company — Restaurant in Milton

This was a super letdown after having such a great experience at the Hingham location. I arrived a few minutes early, but overall it was timely as they handed it to me right out of the oven. I then had a short 9 minute ride home, only to experience shame and disappointment. It sucks when you talk up the food to guests, only to have everyone be super unimpressed and full of regret after the meal.

Ordered wings, 1 large cheese and 1 large clam chowder pizza. The wings were well seasoned, and I like that they don't smother them in any sauces and let the plain flavor shine. However these wings were overcooked and super dry - no indication of any moisture left. An order came with 9 wings. Now onto the pizzas - both were also incredibly overcooked. The crust and dough were so dry, that our mouths and teeth were sore after dinner from pulling, shredding, and trying to chew. Literally cut up our mouths because they were sharp croutons at that point. Also had to actively search for clams on the clam chowder pizza - found maybe 8 tops. Overall such a disappointment since we had great wings and pizza from another location and were excited to try to Milton one. Will not be ordering from here again.

Ordering/delivery also available through doordash and ubereats. Street parking can be a pain around dinner time and will likely have to double park to run...

Really disappointed. We ordered 3 pizzas tonight (Saturday) for my family. I included a Gluten Free pizza in the order for my sister who suffers from a severe gluten allergy with celiac disease. The order came and the Gluten Free pizza was made on regular dough instead of Gluten Free dough. I called at 7:45pm to let them know that the order was incorrect. It took a few phone calls to get through to them as no one was answering. When they finally picked up, the guy on the phone told me they were closed and wouldn’t let me speak. When I explained to him that we were missing the Gluten Free pizza and that a family member has an allergy, he just yelled at me saying they were closed again and then hung up on me. Their hours online say open until 8:30pm; so I called 45 minutes before their closing time and they refused to help.

Not only was this really disappointing as a frequent, longtime customer, but it’s also concerning that they’re dismissive of an allergy. Luckily, we order from here very often so my sister knew by looking at the pizza that it wasn’t on the Gluten Free cauliflower dough. If this was another customer with celiac disease who ordered from Peel for the first time, they wouldn’t have known the difference, would have eaten the pizza and could have gotten very sick. Peel has been our go-to for years now, but we won’t be...

On Easter Sunday we wanted pizza in the evening after a big lunch. I went on line for Milton and ordered a pizza and was given a pickup time. When I got there to pick it up, the restaurant was closed, obviously for Easter. However it allowed me to order and confirmed it but you weren't open. I assumed incorrectly that because I was able to order, with confirmation that you were in fact open. I called today at 4:51, and spoke to a young woman, she said sorry we were closed Easter and the system should not have allowed it. I explained that it did and there were 4 hungry and disappointed guests. She said sorry, I then asked her that's it and she said yes, and that was the end of the conversation. Very...