Papa Johns Pizza — Restaurant in Muskego

I'm not sure how much more I can take of the quality of pizza coming out of the store. I get too many pizzas where the majority of the toppings are in the middle of the pie leaving one inch or more of crust. This makes it difficult to eat as a regular pizza slice. I'd would rather not eat a pizza with a fork. There is no attention to detail. I feel like the staff doesn't care and aren't proud of what they do. I have been a loyal customer for 20 years or more. It's just really disappointing to get pizza after pizza like this. In the past, I've called about my dissatisfaction and received a complementary pizza or two, but I'd prefer to have quality pizzas coming out...

I stopped in a little over a week ago to place an order. The only employee there was Michael, if I remember his name correctly. Simply outstanding service. My order was a bit different than most he's probably received but he took it in stride and really took care of me. We chatted a little bit too as he was getting it ready to go. Very kind man and personable. When I go back next, I hope to see him again. Great job hiring this guy and hopefully he gets...

Ordered a medium pizza and garlic knots. Asked for pizza to be cooked well done and on arrival the pizza was undercooked and cold. While the garlic knots were burnt. Attempted to call the store to speak with a manager and was on hold for over 30 minutes with no one answering. Attempted to call again and still no answer. This was supposed to be our children’s dinner. Very disappointing service and...