Mamma Gina Pizza — Restaurant in New Castle

Today is 8/13/23 And I am telling you about the poor experience I had today at this Pizzeria. Signs are placed all over the outside of the curtains stating they open at 9:30 am. My husband and I are patiently waiting for the place to open. At 9:30 am we hear crickets still. We are both physically disabled and do have a hard time standing. With the curtains still closed, no where was to be sat. My husband looks threw the slit in the curtain and sees numerous pizzas made already. 9:32 am now. He yells out to an employee and he tells the employee the time. The employee says they are closed and raises his hand in a gesture of waving my husband off My husband begins now to call the pizzeria where as soon as they pick up, they hung up on him. The last call at 9:36 am the employee does not hang up on my husband and they finally open the pizzeria. After several more minutes to open the curtains, my husband speaks to the person who claims to be in charge and nothing really is accomplished in the conversation. All my husband and I received after the conversation was ridicule and nasty looks. My husband did inform the so called person in charge that we were disabled and just needed to sit down at the time they were supposed to open. His response was “ what do you want me to do? Fire them for 5 minutes”. I told him a start and finish would have been a simple sorry. I was also informed they did not open till 10 am contrary to the signs We looked forward to coming on the weekends to get a slice of pizza. To many places to get food with a friendly atmosphere. Never again here. My husband and I did not sit down...

Every visit to Mama Gina’s reaffirms why small businesses like this are the irreplaceable heart of the community. Forget soulless online deals or faceless mega-retailers — no amount of free shipping can match the joy of sitting down with their tomato pie pizza: a vegan masterpiece that not only respects but exceeds my culinary expectations every time.

The crust isn’t just a vessel — it’s an experience. Think rich tomato-infused dough, perfectly crisp yet tender, with a flavor that sings of sun-ripened fields and kitchen secrets. Every bite balances comfort with artistry, delivering more than just a meal — it delivers a moment.

And the setting? Mama Gina’s is deeply embedded in the vibrant local rhythm, where the nearby farmers’ market vendors, artisans, and small shops create a living, breathing ecosystem of human connection. It’s a reminder that true community is built plate by plate, handshake by handshake — not one-click by one-click.

If you want more than a meal — if you want belonging — come to Mama Gina’s. Amazon...

A gem off of pizzeria in the middle of farmers market. They have many excellent tasting pizzas but lack a wood fire option. They make a very good Italian type crust as well as a couple of deep dish options. We love that their sauce is not sweet or salty and the pizzas are not overly greasy. Favorites are the sausage and mushroom and onions; spinach and ricotta and fresh tomatoes; the white chicken and broccoli pizza. The best values are a whole 16-in pizza for $24. You can mix and match 8 slices which normally would be $4 each to get the whole pizza price. People also line up for the end of the leftover end of day slices that used to drop down to $2 but I'm not sure if that's still the price. Consider Thursdays or early morning if you want to avoid the crowds or late in...