HTML SitemapExplore

Cookie Jar — Restaurant in New York

Name
Cookie Jar
Description
Brick-walled bakeshop offering traditional cookies, brownies & whimsical cookie jars.
Nearby attractions
Northerleigh Park
North Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Westerleigh Park
Willard Ave. &, Woodbridge Pl, Staten Island, NY 10314
Saturn Playground
Clove Rd &, Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Levy Playground
Jewett Ave. and, Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Nearby restaurants
Metro Pizza
1218 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Forest Bagels
1180 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Call It A Wrap
1198 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Forest Thai
1211 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Gyro King (Staten Island ) FOREST AVE
1267 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Wild Crab House
1209 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Sumac
1198 B Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Sofia's Taqueria Forest
1210 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Polish-European American Deli M.E Inc
1214 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
S & M Polish Deli
1214 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Nearby local services
Da Oscar Nails Salon
1194 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Stop & Shop
1351 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10302
Staten Island Massage & Wellness
1332 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Exotic convenience & SmokeShop
1267 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Nailway Nail Salon
1142 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, United States
G & G Italian Meat Market
1365 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Okin Market Place
1309 Forest Avenue &, Hamlin Pl, Staten Island, NY 10302
J&E Nail Spa
1406 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
T.J. Maxx & HomeGoods
1509 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Liquor Depot
1351 Forest Ave Forest L, Staten Island, NY 10302, United States
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
Cookie Jar tourism.Cookie Jar hotels.Cookie Jar bed and breakfast. flights to Cookie Jar.Cookie Jar attractions.Cookie Jar restaurants.Cookie Jar local services.Cookie Jar travel.Cookie Jar travel guide.Cookie Jar travel blog.Cookie Jar pictures.Cookie Jar photos.Cookie Jar travel tips.Cookie Jar maps.Cookie Jar things to do.
Cookie Jar things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Cookie Jar
United StatesNew YorkNew YorkCookie Jar

Basic Info

Cookie Jar

1226 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
4.6(305)$$$$
Closed
order
order
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

Brick-walled bakeshop offering traditional cookies, brownies & whimsical cookie jars.

attractions: Northerleigh Park, Westerleigh Park, Saturn Playground, Levy Playground, restaurants: Metro Pizza, Forest Bagels, Call It A Wrap, Forest Thai, Gyro King (Staten Island ) FOREST AVE, Wild Crab House, Sumac, Sofia's Taqueria Forest, Polish-European American Deli M.E Inc, S & M Polish Deli, local businesses: Da Oscar Nails Salon, Stop & Shop, Staten Island Massage & Wellness, Exotic convenience & SmokeShop, Nailway Nail Salon, G & G Italian Meat Market, Okin Market Place, J&E Nail Spa, T.J. Maxx & HomeGoods, Liquor Depot
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(718) 448-3500
Website
cookiejarnyc.com
Open hoursSee all hours
Tue10 AM - 7 PMClosed

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in New York
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in New York
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in New York
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
2 Lb Assorted Cookies
dish
1 Dozen Red Velvet Cupcakes
dish
1 Dozen Assorted Cupcakes
dish
Jelly Assorment
dish
2 Lb Rainbow Petit Fours AKA 7 Layer Cookies
dish
Chocolate Explosion
dish
Feeling Nutty
dish
Large Happy Birthday Container With Cookies
dish
Small Happy Birthday Container
dish
Small Smiley Face Container With Cookies
dish
Toasted Marshmallow Milkshake
dish
Red Velvet Cake Shake
dish
Latte
dish
Tea

Reviews

Live events

The Full-Day See It All NYC Tour
The Full-Day See It All NYC Tour
Tue, Jan 13 • 9:00 AM
New York, New York, 10019
View details
Maxs Wake n’ Bake Tour
Maxs Wake n’ Bake Tour
Tue, Jan 13 • 11:00 AM
New York, New York, 10025
View details
The Finest Chinese Food Tour in Flushing Chinatown
The Finest Chinese Food Tour in Flushing Chinatown
Tue, Jan 13 • 12:00 PM
Queens, New York, 11355, United States
View details

Nearby attractions of Cookie Jar

Northerleigh Park

Westerleigh Park

Saturn Playground

Levy Playground

Northerleigh Park

Northerleigh Park

4.4

(61)

Closed
Click for details
Westerleigh Park

Westerleigh Park

4.6

(169)

Closed
Click for details
Saturn Playground

Saturn Playground

4.6

(36)

Closed
Click for details
Levy Playground

Levy Playground

4.2

(68)

Closed
Click for details

Nearby restaurants of Cookie Jar

Metro Pizza

Forest Bagels

Call It A Wrap

Forest Thai

Gyro King (Staten Island ) FOREST AVE

Wild Crab House

Sumac

Sofia's Taqueria Forest

Polish-European American Deli M.E Inc

S & M Polish Deli

Metro Pizza

Metro Pizza

4.6

(299)

$

Closed
Click for details
Forest Bagels

Forest Bagels

4.4

(307)

$

Open until 9:00 PM
Click for details
Call It A Wrap

Call It A Wrap

4.3

(146)

$

Closed
Click for details
Forest Thai

Forest Thai

4.4

(97)

$

Open until 12:00 AM
Click for details

Nearby local services of Cookie Jar

Da Oscar Nails Salon

Stop & Shop

Staten Island Massage & Wellness

Exotic convenience & SmokeShop

Nailway Nail Salon

G & G Italian Meat Market

Okin Market Place

J&E Nail Spa

T.J. Maxx & HomeGoods

Liquor Depot

Da Oscar Nails Salon

Da Oscar Nails Salon

4.3

(23)

Click for details
Stop & Shop

Stop & Shop

4.2

(1.2K)

Click for details
Staten Island Massage & Wellness

Staten Island Massage & Wellness

4.8

(137)

Click for details
Exotic convenience & SmokeShop

Exotic convenience & SmokeShop

4.2

(8)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.

Posts

P ZP Z
I had the pleasure of visiting this cute little bakery on my way to do some shopping. Immediately in awe of the lovely display of cookie jars along the length of one wall of this place. One cannot help but to be captivated by this whimsical display. Perusing through the sweets, I see quite a few unique selections. I decided to try strawberry and lemon flavored cookies. There were also seasonal ones like a pumpkin, Nutella tarts, chocolate chip and an assortment of other flavors. Once back home, I decided to start sampling my selection. The strawberry, in my opinion, tasted a little tart. Lemon as well. Each cookie that I tried, aside from pinoli, kind of had a sort of a shortbread consistency. There is a subtle sweetness. I wouldn't categorize the cookies here to be like something one might expect to find at an Italian bake shop. It is definitely very different than that. I don't know if I will have a chance to return but if I can, I wouldn't mind trying some other things because I like variety.
Thomas P Smith NY REAL ESTATEThomas P Smith NY REAL ESTATE
If you're on the hunt for the ultimate bakery experience, look no further than this gem. The cookies? Absolute perfection. Each bite is a heavenly blend of gooey centers and crispy edges, guaranteed to satisfy even the most discerning sweet tooth. And let's talk about their coffee - it's the ideal companion to those delectable treats. From the first sip to the last crumb, my visit to this bakery was nothing short of delightful.
E KE K
I visited a dessert shop that offered a variety of soft cookies, including several options to choose from. I decided to purchase four chocolate chip cookies, along with a vanilla cupcake and a carrot cupcake. The desserts were notably fresh and not excessively sweet, making them enjoyable. I would particularly recommend the chocolate chip cookies for anyone seeking a satisfying sweet treat.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in New York

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

I had the pleasure of visiting this cute little bakery on my way to do some shopping. Immediately in awe of the lovely display of cookie jars along the length of one wall of this place. One cannot help but to be captivated by this whimsical display. Perusing through the sweets, I see quite a few unique selections. I decided to try strawberry and lemon flavored cookies. There were also seasonal ones like a pumpkin, Nutella tarts, chocolate chip and an assortment of other flavors. Once back home, I decided to start sampling my selection. The strawberry, in my opinion, tasted a little tart. Lemon as well. Each cookie that I tried, aside from pinoli, kind of had a sort of a shortbread consistency. There is a subtle sweetness. I wouldn't categorize the cookies here to be like something one might expect to find at an Italian bake shop. It is definitely very different than that. I don't know if I will have a chance to return but if I can, I wouldn't mind trying some other things because I like variety.
P Z

P Z

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in New York

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
If you're on the hunt for the ultimate bakery experience, look no further than this gem. The cookies? Absolute perfection. Each bite is a heavenly blend of gooey centers and crispy edges, guaranteed to satisfy even the most discerning sweet tooth. And let's talk about their coffee - it's the ideal companion to those delectable treats. From the first sip to the last crumb, my visit to this bakery was nothing short of delightful.
Thomas P Smith NY REAL ESTATE

Thomas P Smith NY REAL ESTATE

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in New York

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

I visited a dessert shop that offered a variety of soft cookies, including several options to choose from. I decided to purchase four chocolate chip cookies, along with a vanilla cupcake and a carrot cupcake. The desserts were notably fresh and not excessively sweet, making them enjoyable. I would particularly recommend the chocolate chip cookies for anyone seeking a satisfying sweet treat.
E K

E K

See more posts
See more posts

Reviews of Cookie Jar

4.6
(305)
avatar
1.0
3y

I have been going to this place for years. My son liked getting cookies from here and so did the rest of the family. Unfortunately, I'm very unhappy with the way they handled an accident involving my 2 year old daughter. I stopped by to get some treats to bring to my friend's house and with me were also my 9 yr old son and my 2 yr old daughter. I had my 2 yr old in my arm as I'm ordering and for a quick minute I put her down as I'm making the payment. I had my 9 yr old holding her and for a split second she grabbed one of the jars from the wall and threw it on the floor. I was upset and of course I offered to pay for the damage. The person who claimed to be the manager was not concerned at all about my child and if we needed any assistance. She rushed telling the person at the register to charge me full price for the jar (very expensive by the way) I left the store feeling hurt, upset, and wondering if a jar ment more to that place than my child who could have gotten a serious cut from it. Disappointed and still hurt and no more visits to...

   Read more
avatar
4.0
2y

I had the pleasure of visiting this cute little bakery on my way to do some shopping. Immediately in awe of the lovely display of cookie jars along the length of one wall of this place. One cannot help but to be captivated by this whimsical display. Perusing through the sweets, I see quite a few unique selections. I decided to try strawberry and lemon flavored cookies. There were also seasonal ones like a pumpkin, Nutella tarts, chocolate chip and an assortment of other flavors. Once back home, I decided to start sampling my selection. The strawberry, in my opinion, tasted a little tart. Lemon as well. Each cookie that I tried, aside from pinoli, kind of had a sort of a shortbread consistency. There is a subtle sweetness. I wouldn't categorize the cookies here to be like something one might expect to find at an Italian bake shop. It is definitely very different than that. I don't know if I will have a chance to return but if I can, I wouldn't mind trying some other things because I...

   Read more
avatar
5.0
4y

I drive 20 minutes to get to this bakery. Best bakery on Staten Island by far. They have about 60 different types of cookies, chocolate covered pretzels & different drinks. Such as bubble tea, cappuccino, hot chocolate, milkshakes, tea and a few others. There's not one cookie they make that's not addicting. Especially the rainbow sprinkled almond cookies and their snow cap cookies & pretzels. I really go there for their pignoli cookies. They are unbelievable and the best price that I've found so far. Another bakery I went to charged $30 a pound for them. They charge $18 for all cookies except the pignoli cookies. Those are $20 a pound. Everytime I go there I walk out with 2 or 3 pounds of cookies and that's what's goes home with me. I had to take a break from...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next