Nonna's Pizza Great Kills — Restaurant in New York

First time I went there, a few weeks ago, there was an argument going on between the men who were doing the deliveries while I was in there trying to order with my child. My little one was nervous and asked to stay in the car cuz it was getting really really loud in there between them. I ordered and to my surprise the pizza was good 👍. Today I went again. The men who do the deliveries, they are all over the place and take up much of the counter space that is intended for the customers who are coming in to order or pick up. I ordered a sicilian slice and a regular slice. I did not look at my order before leaving the store. I get in my car drive off, about five to six blocks later I opened up the box and there is a triangular Sicilian slice. Must have been the first time I've ever seen a triangular Sicilian slice. My little one wasn't too happy about it but I decided it wasn't worth my time to go back and have it changed. Although I must say the pizza is still pretty good but I'll think I'll have to skip it next time and find another...

Nonna’s Pizzeria is a standout, and a big part of that is thanks to Franny and his team. He’s warm, welcoming, and friendly. From the moment you walk in, you feel like family!

They offer every kind of slice you can imagine, and everything I tried was fantastic. I had the vodka slice, a deep dish pepperoni, and ordered the white clam pie - which I’ve never seen offered anywhere else. It’s absolutely incredible: savory, lemony, and full of flavor.

On top of that, I highly recommend checking out their bagel store next door, freshly baked bagels every morning, and just as impressive as the pizza.

Nonna’s is a hidden gem that I’m so glad I found, and I’m already planning to make it a part of my weekly routine. Whether you’re picking up, ordering out, or grabbing a slice to go, don’t miss out...

Everytime I order pizza for delivery the girls never tell the driver apartment door so the driver always gets confused and when I finally get my pizza the crust is always burnt and the pie is overloaded with grease. For 19 dollars you should get a fresh pie that does not look like it was yesterdays reheat. When the pie is fresh it is good but this place has constantly delivered bad pies and that is what made the experience. The girls on the phone don't tell you the total when you give your card & the price flexes between 18.00 & 19.53 when they charge your card what gives?

Dominos has better pies for $7.99 and if you have not tried nonnas yet don't, whether you get a fresh pie or not is a complete gamble & it's 19 dollars tax + tip you end up spending 25 dollars and for what to be disgusted...