Antioch Pizza Shop - Paddock Lake, WI — Restaurant in Paddock Lake

We are new to the area and were looking for a new place for pizza. 1st time we went (a month or so ago) our order was wrong and toppings were scant and looked like they were just tossed on the pizza. We ordered for the first pizza cheese, sausage, and onion. We received our pizza with those toppings plus mushrooms. We ordered a second pizza with pepperoni and cheese. Both pizzas were completely full on the bottom of black remnants from the pizza oven obviously not being clean. Waste of money as my son wouldn’t eat his pizza. Food was hardly warm and we live five minutes away. Fast forward to yesterday 10/20 we thought we would give them a second chance. We ordered the two slice special and the steak sandwich special with everything. We ordered sausage thin and sausage pan for our slices and the thin had clearly been there for awhile, as it was dry, tasteless, and lacked sauce. The pan sausage had a ton of cheese but hardly any crust and what was there was mushy. Our steak sandwich was ordered with everything, which according to the website has garlic bread, onion, mozzarella cheese. What we got was an old, fatty piece of steak with no flavor the bread had a garlic spread on it but was not toasted at all! There was nothing on it no cheese and no onions and again all of our food was just slightly warm. The only reason I gave them two stars was the girl checking is out was very nice. Two visits both times orders were wrong, hardly warm, and food was definitely not up to par. Sadly we have to keep searching for a pizza place and...

So I live in Bristol and have been enjoying the fact that they opened up this location. Have ordered several pizzas for delivery with no problems. Then today I try and order, after 5 minutes of being on hold they tell me that I am out if there delivery range. So you can anticipate my confusion for as all I have gave them was a phone number and all my info including my address was in the system. But yet they don’t deliver to me. So I asked to speak to manager Because I had difficult time understanding why all of a sudden they no longer deliver to me. After 15 minutes of discussion I was told to try the antioch location which also will not deliver to me and they say that I’m in the Salem location. I’m done the pizza is good but not good enough to deal with people who don’t want to work. If they would have simply stated that sorry we were never supposed to deliver to you in the first place and that I’m out if there delivery range I could accept it. But to give me the run around made me upset. Felt like whoever is working tonight just didn’t want to put...

We come to Antioch Pizza VERY often & have ordered their food for birthday parties for the last 5 years. The service used to be great but the staff in there has gotten less friendly & less helpful. Every time we come in there with my kids now, the staff does not even say hello. When we wait at the ice cream cooler to order ice cream, they just stand by the kitchen doors talking and don't even say one minute or we will be right with you, nothing. I have to usually say something again for them to even come by the cooler to help us. The service has progressively gotten worse in there the last year. As far as catering for parties go, the last 4 times we ordered from them, they forgot something in our order or pick up time was way later than we expected. We always order tons of pizza and Italian beefs and they usually forget all the bread to go with it and the beef toppings. Just overall disappointed in their customer service and hope...