Sciortino's Pizza — Restaurant in Perth Amboy

Look at all the 1 star reviews within the last few months. I will never ever come back to this place again. Either management is clueless because the staff is clueless. I called to order a pie with no cheese and said it was because of a cheese allergy and was told that was NOT possible because the pizza is already made. They said they make the pizza in the morning and put cheese on top and reheat it when it’s ordered later in the day with toppings. Then asked if I was okay with that? I said no it’s a cheese allergy. So if it’s a slow day and you order at 7pm. Your pie could have been sitting there for 8 hours. I was told there was nothing they could do and after I said how bout the other 20 times I ordered a pie with no cheese and had no issues. The guy didn’t have a response. Maybe because I was angry when I drove 40 mins to pick up a pie the last time that I ordered that had parmesean cheese on it. After I ordered it without mozzarella or parm twice then also said no cheese at all. No wonder they didn’t answer my call from my Personal phone the first two times. Never again. God rest the original owners soul that his name is...

I ordered chicken alfredo, an eggplant parm and 2 slices of pizza which was $40. Ok no problem. I picked up the order to find out that no chicken was in the chicken alfredo. Just noodles and sauce. So I called them. So the price of the noodles and sauce was $15 and for chicken it's another $5 dollars. So I said this was not what I ordered because I ordered it with chicken on the phone with them when I placed the order. And this was not my fault and can I have my money back. After a little hassle he gave me my $15 dollars back. Went down the block to taco express. Got a order of steak, grilled chicken,pork, rice and beans, and salad with 3 different sauces for $20 with tax was about $22. This pizza place was charging $20 for just...

Just ordered a pie to be delivered and requested 2 paper plates and napkins being that the house is empty and being sold, and there is nothing inside. The girl, Sandy’s daughter, assured me that it would be sent. Needless to say it was not called back and was hung up on not once but twice and told if we don’t like their food not to call them. Called a third time and she didn’t say a word. Unprofessional and absolutely rude. Should definitely not be answering phones or taking orders if you don’t pay attention to the customer. It’s because of the customers that the business is open to begin with....