Cantina Mexicana Sports Bar & Grill — Restaurant in Pleasantville

I literally just left here with my husband. We came to have some delicious Mexican food for dinner after a long day, and we wanted to treat ourselves.

We visited this establishment once before and we had a great experience the last time we came with our cousins visiting from Delaware. We thought we found a hidden gem.

From the initial experience to this most recent visit, it went from a 10 to a zero for me.

They had karaoke tonight, which was cool. People looked to be having a good time.

We arrived around 8:30pm. The dinner menu is available until 10pm, which is the only reason we came.

We chose a spot to sit and were handed regular menus with the regular food items to choose from.

I ordered a coconut margarita as I did the last time I came, it was definitely not the same quality as the one I had prior. I'd rate that a 2 out of 10.

The last coconut margarita I had on the last visit, was the most spectacular drink I have ever had, an easy 10 out of 10.

For food, we originally ordered 10 wings for appetizers ($14) , I ordered veggie chimichangas ($12) and my husband ordered a burger. ($12) - the prices matter further down...

The waiter came back around 9:30pm, way after we ordered and stated that they were now only serving the late night menu - as the person who makes the regular food left.🤔

We originally were going to leave but my husband wanted to stay so we did.

We then ordered from the "after hours" menu given the following: Two orders of 6 wings with fries, I only received 5 wing-dings, not chicken wings, and they were pink inside of 2 of the 5.

Then we get the check - a margarita with house tequila there is $6. I know this from my previous visit...

The "wings" were $12 per person ($24 total) and my husband ordered a lemonade ($3).

They created a bill for $56! The math did not add up correctly.

We just paid without saying anything because we were ready to get out of there.

Note: I noticed that the prices change for after hours/night time. All the prices double and the food is halved in portion size. The quality also depreciates.

I had previously recommended this place to others based on my initial visit. It goes without saying that is no longer the case.

That will definitely be our second and last visit indefinitely. We work really hard and thought this would be a great way to finish our night,...

I had such a good time here! Me and my girls came here for dinner and drinks, we started off with pineapple infused martini and the espresso martini which were both delicious! Then we had the fresh mozz with roasted red peppers which was fresh and full of flavor, we ordered the meatball parm soup with our dinners and that was the best soup I’ve ever had! I could eat it everyday! We had penne vodka With chicken and fettuccine Alfredo with chicken which came out hot and homemade you can tell! We had so much left over to take home for the next day! We had the homemade tiramisu for dessert and I wanted more it was perfect! So Around 10pm the dj came on and we moved to a table by him to drink, dance, and smoke hookah. The music was great he played everything we danced all night! I will...

I absolutely love Mexican food and eat it everywhere we go. Hands-down, this place had the best Authentic Mexican tacos I ever had! The meat had such amazing flavor! Good amounts on everything. The rest of my family was all pleased with their meals as well! The staff was super friendly both times I went! They have an awesome outside area and awesome inside seating and a bar area as well! Also, my father left his credit card there and the waitress walked over to our hotel to return it to him! Amazing Service I cannot say anything bad about this place, Except their sign outside could use an update! lol The sign makes it look deceiving like it’s not a great place but once you walk in,...