Wally's Frozen Custard — Restaurant in Saint Clair Shores

I was excited to try Wally’s Frozen Custard after having Andy’s frozen custard while in Tennessee. My expectations were a bit high going into it so maybe that was my first mistake.

First off, when we arrived the place was packed and there was a whole high school team there being rowdy and causing havoc. So that kind of made the vibe off having to deal with energetic teens being as loud and annoying as possible. But we tried our best to ignore it though. The workers took quite a while getting orders out so that didn’t help either.

My husband and I got their Reese’s Wally’s Whirly. I actually didn’t realize it was Reese’s Pieces instead of Reese’s peanut butter cups. So I was a bit disappointed when we got our order because I’m not really a huge fan of Reese’s Pieces. I had thought we were getting something completely different. I will say, their frozen custard is nothing similar to Andy’s. I actually preferred Andy’s more because it wasn’t as creamy, it was refreshing too. Something really missed the mark with Wally’s.

Maybe I should have expected it to be like Andy’s frozen custard but it was a bit too creamy for me. I get that it’s custard but it just wasn’t satisfying at all for me personally. I’d just stick with Andy’s in all honesty. The experience we had at Wally’s mixed with the disappointing custard...

Went to get a shake and the gentlemen ahead of me with two dogs, allowed one of the animals to jump on the outside serving counter. The employee then proceeded to feed the animal on the counter ice cream cones with her hands! The dog was ecstatic. The owner took the cones and the employee proceeded to rub the animals head and mouth. And yep, you guessed right. I was next. She made my shake without washing her hands or sanitizing the area. I didn’t want to cause a scene but it seemed as if everyone was watching to see if I would explode. I politely asked her to wash her hands. She complied. I understand people love their dogs, but the counter is not a place for your animals. And the servers definitely should not feed...

Came here for the 1st time a few weeks ago, and the line for drive thru was to the street (literally sitting in the street for several minutes) the custard is very very creamy, and the prices are so cheap. Got 5 custards and a quart to go and it was $20 ish. Very friendly staff

Update, we still come to Wally's. It is definitely in our rotation of ice cream places to visit! they are open all year round , they open at 6:00 a.m. because they do have breakfast sandwiches, muffins, and some bagels. They do have weekly flavors other than their chocolate and vanilla custard, this week is orange, so orange vanilla twist it tasts just like a creamsicle! Definitely awesome custard and it is so creamy...