Sheffield Public House — Restaurant in Sheffield

When I first saw the sign announcing that Sheffield Public House was “coming soon,” I was immediately intrigued. Downtown Sheffield doesn’t have a huge variety of sit-down restaurants, so the idea of an English-style pub opening up there definitely caught my attention. I decided to give it a little time after they opened, and about a month later we finally went in to try it—and I’m glad we did, because it turned out to be a really enjoyable experience.

The restaurant has a very inviting vibe that fits the “public house” theme perfectly. Inside, you’ll find warm wood accents, exposed brick finishes, classic mirrors, and framed pictures lining the walls. It’s cozy and atmospheric without being too dark or heavy. The bar area is especially well-designed—it’s clear that some real thought went into both the layout and the look. Whether you’re coming for a casual drink or a full dinner, the seating feels comfortable and gives off that welcoming, pub-style coziness. The lighting also plays a big role—it’s soft, warm, and really makes the space feel alive.

As for the food and drinks, we were very impressed. We started with the hummus and pita appetizer, which was fresh, flavorful, and a great way to kick off the meal. Their drink menu is also worth highlighting—they have a solid selection of cocktails and spirits, plus their own house beer, which I really enjoyed. It’s smooth, balanced, and pairs perfectly with the kind of dishes they serve.

For our main courses, we leaned into the pub classics and ordered the Fish & Chips and the Shepherd’s Pie. Both were excellent. The cod fish in the fish & chips was cooked beautifully—crispy on the outside, tender and flaky on the inside. The Shepherd’s Pie was hearty and flavorful, with that comforting richness you expect from the dish. Everything felt fresh, well-prepared, and elevated beyond just “pub food.”

All in all, Sheffield Public House is a fantastic addition to the Shoals area dining scene. If you’re looking for a place that combines a warm, inviting atmosphere with great food, well-crafted drinks, and that classic pub feel, this is a spot you’ll want to check out. Whether you’re a local or just passing through the beautiful downtown of Sheffield, it’s definitely...

I came here because I saw that their menu online had fish and chips...

By the way, before I finish this, the chef creates and makes all the sauces and desserts, which are really original and great tasting.

So being in alabama with catfish, fillets, everywhere you turn around, I had to come and check out fish and chips, because I love fish and chips almost as much as I like catfish...

And boy was I surprised when I got my meal. These cad fillets were so perfectly breaded and crispy on the outside that I will be back. I've had good Fish and Chips elsewhere. But the chef, here really, is it tries to get it right, and he really nailed it on the head of this perfectly.

Additionally, for an appetizer, we had the mediterranean plate, which is pita bread, hummus, a blend of olives, peppers and relish, and some taziki sauce that is really outstanding.

Their selections of drinks are unique. We also had the mediterranean bloody mary guinness on tap and a straight to ale's double.

We finished off with...

I have been here twice and both times the food and atmosphere were perfect. The first time we got there too late to order from the dinner menu, after 9:00 they change to a limited menu, so I had a house burger and it was delicious and the fries were perfect!!! So the second time I got there early enough to get the Fish and Chips and a Caesar Salad. The fish was fried to crispy/crunchy perfection and did not get soggy. My daughter ordered the fried mushrooms and Shepherds Pie. The mushrooms were unbelievable and the Shepherds Pie was delicious, she recommends both. The atmosphere is cozy but not cramped ,good music, not too loud, and the staff are attentive, patient and eager to explain dishes. We will be back. Highly...