Millie's Market Cafe — Restaurant in Shipshewana

We hosted a 60th surprise party at Millie’s and our experience was wonderful. They allowed us to utilized their space, after business hours for the party and the rooftop patio made for a beautiful setting. Davis and his staff were more than helpful. They were quick to communicate during planning and provided a full meal buffet, quick and delicious. They even allowed us to use the carousel after hours. Hearing the party sing happy birthday while adults and children alike all rode the carousel will forever be a special memory for our entire family....

We were told about this place from a local. The reception wasn't as warm as we would have thought it would be. Service was ok, but impersonal. We assumed it would be much more warm. Food was ok. After seeing all the reviews before going here and since it was recommended by a local, we had higher hopes. Had the cheeseburger and fries, neither had much flavor. Visited on a Tuesday in August, so we figured they would be happy for the business brought in by the flea market... just not what we thought it would be. Maybe we just visited...

It's literally one of the best restaurants I've been to. Most restaurants I review on here are because they weren't good, to say the least. This one was different. So for a bit of back story, I went to the Philippines for about 40 days, and when we got back home in Indiana, most food I wasn't satisfied with because the food here just isn't the same, but here, man I fulfilled me. The mushroom and Swiss is literally the best sandwich I had ever had. The wait times aren't long and the fries are immaculate. I have no complaints. I...